[Fadicuss]

Originally posted by Jaay

After Judas' terrible video and BTW's okay video, I wasn't expecting anything good.

But, LOVED this video. THIS is the Gaga I like. I am not a stan, maybe not even a fan. But I really enjoyed this video. I don't like the over the top **** she is known for, so this video was something I loved. I really loved the instrumental section with her just dancing around. I loved this video, I'm even going to watch it again.

Sometimes less can be more. In the case of this video, it was really true.

I like it too.

My initial feeling is way better than BTW, which I was so disapointed. I guess it's all subjective. TEOG (song) ***** so hard

[Aryl]

Joseph Khan is laughing somewhere.

[!ola]

OK video ...

[beyoncefan1]

I can't believe I switched over from watching Crazy In Love on Fuse to this mess. It's sad cuz I luv this song to death prob one of my faves on the album n while the setting is nice she really did no justice for the song IMO. Idk what is going on wit her video-wise this era but I just need her to get it together. It's sad when Katy Perry's music videos r starting to be more exciting than urs. I mean no shade to Katy cuz I think E.T. and LFN r two of the best videos of the year but I'm just trying to make a point.

[eteru]

The video wouldve been great if she didnt wear any make up and just dressed casually like a regular civilian.

[Kh-Loud]

That 30 sec google chrome commercial >>>>>>>>>>>

[The Knowledge]

She honestly looks like Keri Hilson throughout the whole video.

[KRL]

Originally posted by Rico Shameless v2

I haven't really seen any praise for it, except monsters defending it.

Strange because all I see is fans hating on it but people on blogs are praising its simplicity

[LCTV]

Originally posted by Remeese

All the haters..

keep on walkin' right to that edge.

[MrPeanut]

The thing is, having a fairly straightforward video concept doesn't mean it has to be boring. Single Ladies is a prime example of that.

I just hope I never hear another "tone it down" Gaga complaint again, cuz obviously she can't do it successfully.

[Mani.]

First Gaga is too over the top, but then when she tries "simplicity" she's too boring.
You guys are never satisfied.

[TOASTY]

for me it was pretty boring...it was basically billie jean without dancing at least it gave me billie jean vibes

[Auburn]

I actually don't hate the video, but it is kinda boring. She looks beautiful, the setting is gorgeous, but it's lacking something. Like she could have jumped off the balcony at the end or SOMETHING!

PS She must have come up with the idea when she was sober.

EDIT: I NEED gifs of her fist pumping during the sax solo!

[skyler]

Originally posted by Remeese

All the haters..

gaga doesnt care about them haters

[Cantaloupe.]

Originally posted by LCTV

keep on walkin' right to that edge.

And then right off of it.

[KRL]

They should have added some rain to the vid

[skyler]

Originally posted by Kerihill

She honestly looks like Keri Hilson throughout the whole video.

what? sis...

[D.M.F]

It's decent, Stefani's look was a mess though.

[RihMark]

That was EXTREMELY boring. I take back what I said about wanting her to make things more simple and to try less. I didnt mean in this way. I meant in a fun Poker Face way.

[♥CEB♥]

Um?

I watched the whole five minutes expecting to see more than her weird dancing and make-out session with the sidewalk but I guess not. On the plus side she did look great and it gave me "Billie Jean" teas in the beginning. But, nothing happened. Literally.

You know, simple isn't terrible. I stan for a woman who became an icon off a simple video. But there should be something to hook the audience and Gaga's hair flips weren't enough for me.

I'm sure this video could make some great avis. However, I don't see myself watching it the whole way through again. Judas remains her best.