[J-esper]

Originally posted by Queenofthenight

She got a B+ (83) by Pretty much Amazing and it counts for metacritic http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

[HausOfGerard]

Originally posted by Komet blu

*gaga releases a song*
Critics: This is a copy of *spin giant wheel with M songs* ...La Isla Bonita!

[Whore of Babylon]

Originally posted by State of Grace.

PopMatters saying Dancin’ in Circles sounds like La Isla Bonita
these critics have truly lost it

not la isla bonita

[Phoenixstar]

Madonna comparison is so boring.

[azii]

I'm so happy Hey Girl is doing good on the charts already.

[- JED -]

About to go get the album!!!

[J-esper]

Originally posted by Komet blu

*gaga releases a song*
Critics: This is a copy of *spin giant wheel with M songs* ...La Isla Bonita!

Accurate though, sadly.

[Gladion]

Okay after some more listens

Diamond Heart: 9/10
A-Yo: 7/10
Joanne: 7/10
John Wayne: 9/10
Dancin' In Circles: 10/10
Perfect Illusion: 8/10
Million Reasons: 9/10
Sinner's Prayer: 9/10
Come To Mama: 10/10
Hey Girl: 10/10
Angel Down: 10/10
Grigio Girls: 10/10
Just Another Day: 9/10
Angel Down (Work Tape): 9/10

Average: 9/10 = 90%

A super consistent album. I prefer the 2nd half by a lot tbh, which I know is kinda the unpopular half, but to me it's the best. DH + JW + MR could become 10/10's, still note sure, I'm starting to like DH a loooot more

[Drama]

Diamond heart is the best song on the album.

But idk as a whole I don't think I'm feeling it. Not that it's bad, I just was looking for a poker face-ish, disco stick esque, rah rah type of album lol.

This is sooooo slow and county western ish...

Idk y'all recommend any songs besides diamond heart?

[Ramos]

Did somebody figure out how people outside the US can get the album for 3.99 on Amazon?

I want to give Gaga my coins

[DoubleDutchess]

Just got the e-mail. My album is coming. (Only next week sadly)

[Auraeolux]

My favorite review so far

Only the realization that Gaga is talking to a ghost who never held flesh for her, keeping alive a relationship born wholly in her imagination, does the song's eeriness pay off.

[Pop]

Originally posted by State of Grace.

PopMatters saying Dancin’ in Circles sounds like La Isla Bonita
these critics have truly lost it

It just shows how little the critics know about music history these days.

DIC literally sounds nothing like La Isla Bonita. It sounds more like Ace Of Base, if anything

[Vertigo Stick]

Originally posted by Komet blu

*gaga releases a song*
Critics: This is a copy of *spin giant wheel with M songs* ...La Isla Bonita!

this is so true

Angel Down sounds like *spins wheel* Hung Up

[DoubleDutchess]

Originally posted by State of Grace.

PopMatters saying Dancin’ in Circles sounds like La Isla Bonita
these critics have truly lost it

I just ****ing can't.

[Almodusa]

Today's the day y'all
I'll still be shy buying a Lady Gaga album though
Going to a mall after work to buy it - should I get it at BestBuy where it's more intimate cuz it feels empty or upstairs at Target? Why am I this anxious

[Lawliet]

I love the album


Perfect illusion and million reasons sound so much better listening to the album at whole.


Angel down is my favorite song

[Aviana]

Originally posted by Almodusa

Today's the day y'all
I'll still be shy buying a Lady Gaga album though
Going to a mall after work to buy it - should I get it at BestBuy where it's more intimate cuz it feels empty or upstairs at Target? Why am I this anxious

That's why I bought my physical copies online

[Vertigo Stick]

I attempted to rank this album and I cannot! I can't wait to go home and listen

[Canonical Ensemble]

Originally posted by Drama

Diamond heart is the best song on the album.

But idk as a whole I don't think I'm feeling it. Not that it's bad, I just was looking for a poker face-ish, disco stick esque, rah rah type of album lol.

This is sooooo slow and county western ish...

Idk y'all recommend any songs besides diamond heart?

Perfect Illusion!


Jk, maybe Just Another Day? Have you listen to the bonus tracks?