Quote:
Originally posted by Jeff Koons
Agree. She knows that in order to build a respectful legacy, she needs to lose some to win some.
She's always been like that, though.
|
Right now she is not building a respectful legacy but destroying what she had achieved from 2009-2011. Literally not a single song we have heard so far from Joanne has the power to build legacy. To destroy legacy? Yes. To build? No. You build legacy with songs that are universally accepted and loved- like Poker Face, Bad Romance, The Edge of Glory. I am not saying that she needs to make this kind of songs for the rest of her career. You build a legacy with albums like The Fame Monster- liked by everyone- fans and critics. Yet again, I am not saying she has to make albums with this sound for the rest of her career.
You said 'she needs to lose some to win some'
Ever since Joanne era started she has been losing fans and not winning some. Hence why Perfect Illusion flopped and basically no one cared about it but the Monsters even tho a big part of them did not like it.
Regarding the thread title, No, Joanne is not a brave reinvention. Its just bad music. You can reinvent yourself and not jump in another music genre. You can reinvent yourself by still making pop songs. She basically reinvented herself after The Fame with Bad Romance. It sounded nothing like the singles from The Fame, yet it was loved by the GP and is seen as a classic Gaga song. Maybe she will have more luck next time. Sadly, she really had the hype this time and people were rooting for her
