[Humunukuapua]

Originally posted by Torturo

That's your opinion, other think it is



Well considering some of them want her to create some generic trash that's playing on radio now just so she can get a hit says a lot. Many of them are more concerned wheter something will be a hit instead whether they will like something

No. Most people just want good music.

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Concept & Theory

The song didn't have enough exposure, that's right, but GP won't care about it either way. There's nothing special about it. And honestly, if someone is willing to hear rock music, who will pick a Lady Gaga's track? Gimme a break. It is pretty comprehensible if some fans don't like PI (me included), that's not what made us Gaga's fans and that's not what we are expecting from her. On the other hand, it's also understandable that other fans love it, since they consider it to be an "evolution", even though I am not that versatile when it comes to music genres.

How can you know what people will think about something.
This isn't even rock

I wasn't criticizing you for not liking it, do it. I was criticizing people who want her to sell out and get some tropical house track just cause thats what they think would smash. Also people who feel the need to repeat 50x a day how much song sucks etc. I understand people might not be into something and that's fine, but no need to push that opinion on the others. Saying they are delusional for liking it, that everyone hates it, that ppl are just pretending to like it etc..

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Humunukuapua

No. Most people just want good music.

So why are you complaining, she gave you what you wanted

[Ramos]

It wasn't love!
It wasn't love!
It was another flop

[Vertigo Stick]

The geepee has responded to the song when given the limited exposure it's had. It has little do with the song being good or not and more to do with Gaga being musically irrelevant since like 2011. No one is checking for ha, deal and move on

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Peroxide

I'm just establishing what the majority seem to be saying... songs like Into You, Run Away With Me, Kiss It Better, Do What U Want etc... are marvelled by ATRL (and the gays of the inter-web) because they're largely considered fantastic pop songs. Since February 2011 Gaga's always been polarising with her leads... Born this Way, Applause etc... but Perfect Illusion seems to be the first one where the vast majority are under the impression the song is just a bit pants...

I haven't cared about the charts since Do What U Want...

But most of songs from that list flopped so it doesn't fit these people I was talking about.

And I wasn't talking about you, I was talking about people who do that

[Peroxide]

BUT nobody here is saying she should go work with the Chainsmokers and put out tropical dance tracks... I honestly think if she'd have done that the backlash would have been twice as worse for Gaga trend hopping...

Gaga's just released a song which is basically twink repellent...

[Gladion]

The fact that it might not even go gold WW

[Flexus]

Anyone in the US know the Apple Music chart position?

[L.B GAGA]

Originally posted by Torturo

Yeah but at least they are showing true face, we see who is here for gaga as an evolving artist and who is here for "smash bops"

Evolving takes quality in all parts, the music, videos etc
BTW was evolving with Quality, though BtW video then Judas(perfect bop with future huge potential,released at the wrong time killed by Gaga, it was just the wrong time for it and ruined the whole eras potential, thus killing the energy )
P.I is average good but outdated most definitely, not single worthy but album worthy depending on how well it fits into the whole album concept, hopefully the album has quality music, which compliments PI.
Mary Jane Holland is evolving with quality,same with Artpop,Sexxx dreams but J&D is a mess, even Cake Like lady gaga should just have been re-used and placed there. Dope what happened to I wanna be with you? That's evolving,dope is an outdoor performance piece.
Don't remind me of the fake promises of videos for each song on Artpop.

Anyway i jut think Gaga is executing her eras horrendously even the G.P and her huge fanbase that's massively shrinking is responding to her gone Passion,fake promises,Gaga is over videos and are less interested, each album of hers has some good bops but i have no idea how the sabotages keep halting everything. I mean DWUW was a bop that had major potential (a good video would have taken it far) and after we would have received Sexxx Dreams or
Venus( ). Anything after that bop being utilised properly would have smashed. Also G.U.Y was bound to flop, that gap of boredom after applause and no video for DWUW. Was expected.

Guys lets just wait for JOANNE if its a mess, then may the meltdowns begin. We may be surprised at how good it is and fits perfectly into the album track P.I Unless the good sis Gaga decides to suck the life out of Joannes potential and take away what she promised each era.


Oh and her sales came from her fanbase mostly, not the G.P in majority,especially during the BTW era. But her fanbase has shrunk and its a fact.

[Gladion]

Originally posted by truthteller

what a long promo day.

A kii I laughed

[Ramos]

If I had to describe with one word the Perfect Illusion era it would be "uneventful".

The most boring single era, even the C2C era had a lot of promo spots that made it more interesting than the PI era.

I do love Perfect Delusion though.

[Torturo]

Originally posted by HausofNiko

The fact that it might not even go gold WW

Since when WW certifications exist?

It will go at least Gold in US, she will end up with at least 300k sales, and should have enough streams for at least 200k

(i'm saying at lest just in case she decides to promote)

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Peroxide

BUT nobody here is saying she should go work with the Chainsmokers and put out tropical dance tracks... I honestly think if she'd have done that the backlash would have been twice as worse for Gaga trend hopping...

Gaga's just released a song which is basically twink repellent...

I guess you just didn't see all mess in these threads cause they are many who want that

[Peroxide]

I'm sorta hoping this album was something Gaga just needed to get out of her system...

Once she's gotten bored of cooking chicken, farming and hanging out with Tony a light bulb will turn on and she'll say to herself "oh wait, I'm Lady f*cking Gaga, THE greatest pop star of the digital age"... let's go make an amazing pop album with a huge tour and kick ass visuals.

[SpinThatShhh]

Originally posted by HausofNiko

The fact that it might not even go gold WW

She's not flopping that badly.

She'll probably cross 250k with the US, UK, Canada, France and Australia alone next week.

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Peroxide

let's go make an amazing pop album with a huge tour and kick ass visuals.

She said tour won't be stripped down, so there is at least that

[Aden]

Originally posted by ivi

gaga earned enough money to never work again. she is doing what makes her happy at the moment and i'd rather take a happy gaga than a depressed gaga.

I love how several Twitter Monsters are trying to argue that sales do matter because she needs it for her income as if she's not worth nearly $300 million.

[Gladion]

If perfect illusion was on her previous albums how would you rank it?

The Fame: #7-#8 ish, a decent album track
The Fame Monster: #9, I like teeth a tad better
Born This Way: #13, the album is just too good
ARTPOP:#6 a pretty good album track

[ivi]

i just want her to perform and talk.

i guess we'll get that around album time. 3 more weeks.