[PrinceLightning]

Originally posted by Afferty

I wonder if this song could be a single if it was on Born This Way it's at the same level with Highway Unicorn or Black Jesus

So Highway and BJ are very good songs? I have to agree with you

[monsterLd]

Originally posted by Dämon

I won't waste my time w/ fans who still refuse to understand the Gaga from 2009 is NOT coming back. Deal with it. Deal with the fact even Gaga realized she didn't wanna work with RedOne today, because his productions = outdated trash, and not what she wanted to do.

I'll say it again: Perfect Illusion is better than her both lead singles produced by RedOne. Another proof y'all overrate RedOne.

Couldn't have said it any better.

[Salvatore]

You guys still here?
The hate towards Gaga in here is so pathetic that has really discouraged me from entering on ATRL. They truly ruined every moment about PI and PI is AMAZING. Objectively. Especially when those people stanned for Work, Make Me and Formation which ALL were dragged to shreds. Except for Make Me though because no one even knew it was out from what I can remember.

But I wanted to ask you... Has it grown to you too guys? Everyone seems to dislike it at first and then LOVE it lmao.

[Emperor]

Originally posted by Nutitle

These vocals >>>>>>>>
PI vocals could never

I was so happy when she release this , i thought her new album/ singles were going to be funk/ disco.
Poor me

[Nutitle]

Originally posted by Arcane_Sky

PI is a grower of a song and I agree that compared to her other singles it is in the lower tier.

Marry The Night is the lowest of them all for me, I don't know why I still don't like the song.

MTN is amazing wtf? repent

[Dämon]

Originally posted by The Unforgiving

So Just Dance, Poker Face, Bad Romance, Alejandro and Judas were not great?

Honey those were some of her biggest tracks in between 2008 and 2010's.

There's no denying that she and RedOne can do magic together (if done right).

None of them is in her top 3, so they're really not her greatest, nope.

[monsterLd]

Originally posted by Nutitle

These vocals >>>>>>>>
PI vocals could never

Ugh I so hope this is a deluxe track on the album

[Vertigo Stick]

Originally posted by Dämon

I won't waste my time w/ fans who still refuse to understand the Gaga from 2009 is NOT coming back. Deal with it. Deal with the fact even Gaga realized she didn't wanna work with RedOne today, because his productions = outdated trash, and not what she wanted to do.

I'll say it again: Perfect Illusion is better than her both lead singles produced by RedOne. Another proof y'all overrate RedOne.

So true. Gaga is not having it anymore. If you want RedOne bops replay TFM.

[Afferty]

Originally posted by PrinceLightning

Thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis. The Fame Gaga is not coming back. She's dead and burried. It's ridiculous how her fans want her to stay the same when Gaga is an artist that is changing again and again. Like!?!?!!?

Artist of my ass. Her voice is great amd that's it. Her creativity and songwriting always lack something she looks like a Artschool freshman who tries to look cool and different to prove how uniqe she is. No, she is not an artist and never was.

[lightstheyblindme]

Originally posted by BlackAura

same

[PrinceLightning]

Originally posted by Salvatore

You guys still here?
The hate towards Gaga in here is so pathetic that has really discouraged me from entering on ATRL. They truly ruined every moment about PI and PI is AMAZING. Objectively. Especially when those people stanned for Work, Make Me and Formation which ALL were dragged to shreds. Except for Make Me though because no one even knew it was out from what I can remember.

But I wanted to ask you... Has it grown to you too guys? Everyone seems to dislike it at first and then LOVE it lmao.

True. Such bad songs and PI is in it's first 2 days and they are overdramatic. PI is amazing.

[Gladion]

It's gotten better for me, keep in mind #25 on Gagas discography is probably #3 or #4 in any other girls discography it's just she literally made pop perfection with BTW/TFM so it's kind of hard to compare, but I'm really liking perfect illusion. It's kind of giving me work vibes. I HATEDDDDD work at first, and then I loved it. I didn't hate perfect illusion at first but I didn't LOVE it. I really like it now

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Vertigo Stick

So true. Gaga is not having it anymore. If you want RedOne bops replay TFM.

One would hope they'd do that and leave us alone, but nah.

[Tuxedo]

There's a reason 2 of her Top 3 greatest songs are from BTW. The other one is from TFMo-mo-mo-monster.

[Salvatore]

Originally posted by PrinceLightning

True. Such bad songs and PI is in it's first 2 days and they are overdramatic. PI is amazing.

It's just sad when you see fans of artists who can't and haven't sung live for years criticise on Gaga's vocals. Anyway... I'm honestly so in love with PI and everyone around me seems to love it.

I CANNOT wait for the video

[Raster]

I don't care what direction she takes

I'll probably dig LG5 either way

[puffpuffpass626]

Originally posted by Dämon

I won't waste my time w/ fans who still refuse to understand the Gaga from 2009 is NOT coming back. Deal with it. Deal with the fact even Gaga realized she didn't wanna work with RedOne today, because his productions = outdated trash, and not what she wanted to do.

I'll say it again: Perfect Illusion is better than her both lead singles produced by RedOne. Another proof y'all overrate RedOne.

More like this song is overrated by little monsters, once again, this song was overhyped by the producers and didn't meet expectations.

[Tutankhamun]

Ugh the musical direction/production is not the problem with Perfect Illusion. In fact, the instrumental is pretty dope. It was the messed up mixing that buried all the intricacies of the production and the topline is badly written. And repeating the same monotonic melody for 2 minutes is not gonna help either. I'm not familiar with the way RedOne and Gaga collaborate but I assume it's Gaga doing the songwriting and Redone doing the production?

[Optimus]

Originally posted by PrinceLightning

Thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis. The Fame Gaga is not coming back. She's dead and burried. It's ridiculous how her fans want her to stay the same when Gaga is an artist that is changing again and again. Like!?!?!!?

Why cant you and other RedOne haters understand that we do not want 2009 Gaga back with her weird outfits and her wigs with bangs and the same productions? All we want is just the quality music back. And who served fhe quality music? RedOne. No one can deny that her best music is produced by him and as soon as Gaga abandoned him, she started flopping. The potential commercial success has nothing to do with us wanting RedOne back. It just happened that her best songs are her best selling ones too. And no wonder Perfect Illusion is flopping- people are not here for this kind of music from Gaga.

[The Unforgiving]

Originally posted by PrinceLightning

Thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis. The Fame Gaga is not coming back. She's dead and burried. It's ridiculous how her fans want her to stay the same when Gaga is an artist that is changing again and again. Like!?!?!!?

No one is saying that she should recreate the same sounds over and over again. I mean I still remember ARTPOP.


Us, #TeamRedOne say that she's at her best when she's with Nadir. DJWS sabotaged ARTPOP, yet another proof that she can't escape him. I don't know about Mark but I feel that it might be another DJWS situation, judging from PI. But hopefully Nadir and Fernando will make a return.

Y'all thought that ARTPOP would smash but trashed DJWS for overproducing it, remember that?