Even if we think some landmark albums like Rumours or Homogenic should be higher, they seem accurately (and highly) placed by ATRL standards
B2B being above BTB though. Gosh.
It's not that I think either should be higher but there's a lot of Bjork stans on here (I don't know how many submitted tho) and even non-Bjork stans have admiration for Homogenic. It's a surprise lol
It's not that I think either should be higher but there's a lot of Bjork stans on here (I don't know how many submitted tho) and even non-Bjork stans have admiration for Homogenic. It's a surprise lol
Exactly. Same with OK Computer. Back to Black and Rumours. This countdown is super fishy. No points system or calculation method was revealed, no voters or numbers of any kind revealed. And the whole "i tried to include most albums, so no one gets angry" to top it off is just utter BS.
I don't think that's it, we know what site we're on.
But If albums with one point were the albums in the bubbling under, pretty much everyone's entire list charted.
And i dont think that's the case, I highly doubt a Ghostface Killah album is in the top 40 of an ATRL rate.
Same girl.
I don't remember my list album for album, I deleted it idk why, but I put another Tupac album, Enter The Wu-Tang, Paid In Full, and It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back.
I know for sure those aren't making it along with Al Green.
Yeah, I don't fully remember my list either, but except for like 3 albums, nothing from it has reached the top 100 so far, and I don't see most of the other 22 making it.
Yeah, I don't fully remember my list either, but except for like 3 albums, nothing from it has reached the top 100 so far, and I don't see most of the other 22 making it.
It's safe to say the rest of mine will probably not appear either except maybe Pet Sounds since others voted for it as well and I haven't seen it yet. The rest will be a surprise for me.
I'm also surprised that I haven't seen a Kanye album yet.
It would've been nice to include who voted for what album along with points, instead of having the participants doing it themselves, that way any paranoia/doubts would've been avoided. Not sure if it's the OP's first time doing a rate but usually that's how it happens. Even if that takes time, it would feel appropriate. Anyway this top 40 could look mighty weird.
I'm also surprised that I haven't seen a Kanye album yet.
But we've seen albums by Jason Isbell, Sara Bareilles, Cheryl Cole, Troye Sivan and many more of the kind!
---
Looking at how many people already mentioned voting for Homogenic it surely would have been higher. It was my #10.
Also, as much as I love Otis Redding, I don't believe Otis Blue could chart higher than the beloved What's Going On by Marvin Gaye and almost as high as OK Computer. This rate
It's safe to say the rest of mine will probably not appear either except maybe Pet Sounds since others voted for it as well and I haven't seen it yet. The rest will be a surprise for me.
I'm also surprised that I haven't seen a Kanye album yet.
Honestly there's been a lot of contradictions and this is all really confusing
I see MBDTF making it later on though.
Quote:
Originally posted by Brando
Looking at how many people already mentioned voting for Homogenic it surely would have been higher. It was my #10.
Yeah, even though it's not my fave Björk album, I'm pretty sure I put Homogenic as my #2 since it had the highest chance to chart high cause it's her most loved album.
I'm the only person to mention they voted for Otis Blue so far and I only had it at 17
Quote:
Originally posted by theblackestday
Yeah, even though it's not my fave Björk album, I'm pretty sure I put Homogenic as my #2 since it had the highest chance to chart high cause it's her most loved album.
The amount of expose
Who the **** is MasterXposed and who let her run this countdown
Okay i'm over it, i just wanted to do this for fun but it's not anymore, i'm not gonna be posting the rest. Thanks to everyone who submitted and i'm sorry this had to happen.
ok i don't wanna be annoying OP because everyone is coming for you now but maybe just do this rate like all the other rates have been done. #1 gets 20 points and #20 gets 1 point.
i know that means you have to recount the votes and start the list over but i'll be happy to help you and we can ask someone else to help too. i know you have a personal life and can't be on the ATRL 24/7 but it doesn't have to be done in one day.
i know your not cheating and this is just a suggestion. if you still want to finish the rate using your formula it's totally fine and sorry for complaining
(I really don't remember my list correctly 
)
