[Almost Home]

Originally posted by wanderlust

so music only started from 2000?

it's not OF ALL TIME

gosh

Having one of the most critically acclaimed releases of the past 16 years is nothing to look down upon.

[Marla Singer]

Originally posted by Mariano

yeah acc. to metacritic white people don't make good music 7 out of 10 are black. I am not saying it's impossible, but white artists in general are at least 3 times more than black artists (since it's like that in the population itself), yet ......

I don't believe these are the top 10 best albums of all time And it evidently proves that metacritic is biased.

[wanderlust]

Originally posted by QueenBeyoncé

The most acclaimed pop girl album of all time. Legend. Well deserved.

it's not. like a prayer is. and M wrote and produced most of it

[wanderlust]

Originally posted by Almost Home

Having one of the most critically acclaimed releases of the past 16 years is nothing to look down upon.

the title of this thread is not true. its not of all time because they just count critics from 2000 and later. whats so hard to get?

[Almost Home]

Originally posted by wanderlust

im not doing that am i?

but the title of this thread is just not true. its not of all time because they just count critics from 2000 and later. whats so hard to get?

''Metacritic's Top 10 Albums of All Time'' is what it says in the title.

Reading is fundamental. Metacritic only started compiling reviews 16 years ago. Same way Nielsen Soundscan started tracking sales in '91 so in that aspect there's NOTHING wrong with what was said.

Way to try to spin it.

[Timber]

Blacks have always excelled musically and are the inventors of nearly every damn genre in America. The fact that blacks are more musically acclaimed is no suprise to me at all. They have to work harder to et recognition in racist America, and the result of that, is more quality.

[Timber]

Brian Wilson!

I heard he worked on Good Vibrations for 6 months! Excellent song!

[Mariano]

yeah ok drag me

What I meant is that Metacritic is biased towards RnB, Urban and Rap.

Most of the most acclaimed albums are those 3 genres. And those genres are dominated by black people.

I didn't mean any offence to anyone, I apologize.

Pop music is always trashed and it's mainly by white artists. I guess it's not about race, but genre, but then again, it's corelated in a way, no ?

Idk why y'all jumped on me like that and calling me racist is stupid. You may think I'm ignorant, but I am not racist, nor have I ever been.

http://www.metacritic.com/browse/alb...e/all/filtered

And I didn't even mean it in general, I simply think it's like that on Metacritic. I didn't say those albums are not good. I just have always thought metacritic are biased.

And I agree that grammys is the opposite, I never said it's ok. But grammys have given recognition to black artists far more often than Metacritic does to POP artists.

Again I apologize, not cuz y'all murdered me, but yeah now that I re-read my post, the part about black/white artists was stupid. But I stand by my point, I believe that metacritic are biased when it comes to genres. That doesn't mean that I don't find these albums good. It's just that there are other pop albums that deserve the same recognition and it doesn't even have to do with my fav.

[Bicassie]

Originally posted by Mariano

yeah ok drag me

What I meant is that Metacritic is biased towards RnB, Urban and Rap.

Most of the most acclaimed albums are those 3 genres. And those genres are dominated by black people.

I didn't mean any offence to anyone, I apologize.

Pop music is always trashed and it's mainly by white artists. I guess it's not about race, but genre, but then again, it's corelated in a way, no ?

Idk why y'all jumped on me like that and calling me racist is stupid. You may think I'm ignorant, but I am not racist, nor have I ever been.

http://www.metacritic.com/browse/alb...e/all/filtered

And I didn't even mean it in general, I simply think it's like that on Metacritic. I didn't say those albums are not good. I just have always thought metacritic are biased.

And I agree that grammys is the opposite, I never said it's ok. But grammys have given recognition to black artists far more often than Metacritic does to POP artists.

Again I apologize, not cuz y'all murdered me, but yeah now that I re-read my post, the part about black/white artists was stupid. But I stand by my point, I believe that metacritic are biased when it comes to genres. That doesn't mean that I don't find these albums good. It's just that there are other pop albums that deserve the same recognition and it doesn't even have to do with my fav.

You do know that metacritic is NOT the one choosing the score's............critical music reviewers are their sources for those score's............you are saying that critical music reviewers are biased?

[Mani.]

Lmao, shutup.

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Bicassie

You do know that metacritic is NOT the one choosing the score's............critical music reviewers are their sources for those score's............you are saying that critical music reviewers are biased?

yeah I know, by metacritic, I mean critics.

Yeah most critics are biased against pop music.

And yeah I apologize again now that I think about it Rock music also gets higher scores than POP and those are mostly white artists.

I simply don't believe that the great pop albums aren't on par with the great RnB/Urban/Rap/Rock albums.


Anyway congrats to Bey, I love the album and music is subjective in general, so that whole critics thing is pointless in my opinion, I should've just kept my opinion to myself, considering I didn't even express it the way I wanted to.

[Bey Admired]

Originally posted by Mariano

yeah I know, by metacritic, I mean critics.

Yeah most critics are biased against pop music.

And yeah I apologize again now that I think about it Rock music also gets higher scores than POP and those are mostly white artists.

I simply don't believe that the great pop albums aren't on par with the great RnB/Urban/Rap/Rock albums.

Pop just means popular. Lemonade is therefore pop. This thread is about Lemonade.

[Sharie]

Originally posted by Tutankhamun

And the most overrated album of all time on my list.

Exactly

[Temporal]

Slay mama!

[Brite Lites ☆]

The fumes in here
Congrats to Bey
And screaming at #1 having a 99 based on 8 reviews

[Ressti]

Originally posted by Brite Lites ☆

The fumes in here
Congrats to Bey
And screaming at #1 having a 99 based on 8 reviews

I think albums with less than 15 reviews should be placed lower tbh.

[Rentboy]

Critics always jizz over black artists music more especially when its deemed to be lyrically worthy or preachy. They wanna look cool and hip, like theyre down with the urban vibe. Critics are mostly posers after all.

And yes, all time is not the same as 16 years. It ignores literally thousands of albums and hundreds of classics.

[ShouldersSideways]

Originally posted by Rentboy

Critics always jizz over black artists music more especially when its deemed to be lyrically worthy or preachy. They wanna look cool and hip, like theyre down with the urban vibe. Critics are mostly posers after all.

And yes, all time is not the same as 16 years. It ignores literally thousands of albums and hundreds of classics.

Feel better?

[SaDaré]

Queen of acclaim.

[moonlight.]

a masterpiece getting its deserved praise and a LEGEND getting her deserved acclaim, a true slay