[Anticipating]

Originally posted by HumanitySector

Gaga doesn't have any classic songs that's true. People will only remember her (maybe) for her costumes.

This is true.

[holyground]

LFN and Roar by Katy or Stay/Diamonds by Rihanna

[BadHabits]

Originally posted by Shamser

I am talking classic in terms of sound and lyrics.I think that while JD,PF and BTW are iconic hits they are not classic.They are very of it's time and dated unlike LFN and Roar by Katy or Stay/Diamonds by Rihanna that didn't really age and would sound fresh years to come.
Her songs also lacks big anthem-like choruses.I kinda think that TEOFG and You & I would be more remembeber than her dance songs 10-20 years from now.
What do you think?

Baby More Time is a classic, but if Britney released it now, it would sound dated not fresh, along with Crazy, they both have a sound that's of their era.

Girls Just Wanna Have Fun is a classic but it too would sound dated if released today.

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by Shamser

In few years You and I would be way more remembered and used in media.

but not because of the video hehe

[Optimus]

Originally posted by holyground

And the funniest thing is that neither katy nor rihanna have classic songs

[Teneo]

Originally posted by Baby Boy

You & I is a classic when it's still struggling to reach 100 million views on VEVO despite going top ten in 2011?

Yet it is remembered by the GP, the lyrics are known and it's used in a lot of TV shows and stuff. A classic =/= sales.

[SupahBass05]

Originally posted by HumanitySector

Gaga doesn't have any classic songs that's true. People will only remember her (maybe) for her costumes.

Very true.

[Aqua]

Originally posted by Optimus

BOMT is not a classic tho
so I'd call Poker Face the most classic pop hit since I will Always Love You

A prime example of when blind hatred and delusion overrides all logic

[Truffle.]

Originally posted by JustWilliam

Baby More Time is a classic, but if Britney released it now, it would sound dated not fresh, along with Crazy, they both have a sound that's of their era.

Girls Just Wanna Have Fun is a classic but it too would sound dated if released today.

CIL sounds fresh today but in general I agree with this

[CaptainMusic]

Just because something's dated doesn't mean it's not a classic, Poker Face & Bad Romance are classics.

[Truffle.]

Originally posted by Instinct

A prime example of when blind hatred and delusion overrides all logic

n now they're taking it too far

[Yanko]

dated unlike LFN and Roar by Katy

embarrassing

[WalkingOnCharts]

Originally posted by Mariano

Umbrella is as big of a classic as Poker Face, I forgot about it.

And possibly Crazy in Love.

The others are NOT close.

Umbrella
Crazy in Love
Firework
I kissed a Girl
We Found Love
Dark Horse
Hot n Cold
Love Story
California Gurls
Cool for the Summer
Roar

Poker Face would maybe come after those imo

[Mariano]

So funny how people on ATRL can't find the difference between a song being a classic and a song being relevant.

Yeah Firework is quite relevant, but it's not a bigger classic than Poker Face, Crazy in Love etc. It's just more relevant.

Furthermore a classic most of the times carries the essence of its time.

Give me an example of a classic (10 years or older) that does NOT sound dated

Originally posted by WalkingOnCharts

Umbrella
Crazy in Love
Firework
I kissed a Girl
We Found Love
Dark Horse
Hot n Cold
Love Story
California Gurls
Cool for the Summer
Roar

Poker Face would maybe come after those imo

:fsgadfkadfhjkar Stop

[RoarRiteNow1]

Originally posted by HumanitySector

Gaga doesn't have any classic songs that's true. People will only remember her (maybe) for her costumes.

I agree, especially the part about the costumes

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

BOMT is a classic


like what are y'all doing in here

[Truffle.]

Originally posted by Teneo

Yet it is remembered by the GP, the lyrics are known and it's used in a lot of TV shows and stuff. A classic =/= sales.

No.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

The amount of Gaga threads in the past few days

She does and I certainly wouldn't take atrl forum members their words when they say otherwise

[Baby Boy]

Originally posted by Teneo

Yet it is remembered by the GP, the lyrics are known and it's used in a lot of TV shows and stuff. A classic =/= sales.

I didn't mention sales.

[DanceForYou]

Originally posted by Instinct

A prime example of when blind hatred and delusion overrides all logic

Can we acknowledge some of your fellow Britney stans are exhibiting the same thing in this very thread?