[Berries]

How have two people already submitted?! Stop them, Prismatic!

I will be doing this!

[Prismy]

Originally posted by JakeKills

Didn't Good Girl Gone Bad come out in 2008? Why was it snubbed in favor of these Janet, Britney, and Mariah albums?

This rate is supposed to bring back used albums in the two rates posted in the OP!

GGGB was just recently featured in PQS.

[Vilppu]

Originally posted by Delilah.

i literally dont know what discipline songs to pick and i refuse to listen

janet stans: HELP

Feedback
Rock Wit U
Discpline

and use a randomizer for the other two or something, it's not like anybody actually cares.

Originally posted by JakeKills

Didn't Good Girl Gone Bad come out in 2008? Why was it snubbed in favor of these Janet, Britney, and Mariah albums?

2007. Reloaded was released in 2008 though.

[Delilah.]

i didnt feel like listening to all these albums again (ive heard them all a few times) so i just picked the ones that i remembered from the albums i havent listened to in like 3 years (fearless, discipline, e-mc2)

--

if the hard candy picks get messed up

1. give it 2 me
2. shes not me
3. devil wouldnt recognize you
4.miles away
5. 4 minutes

[Reverie]

Cool!
Discipline will get rightfully dragged, sorry Janet

[Superpower]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

Is it really overrated? It's such a bad song!

Radio is the second most-hated song by Bey stans but it's a 10 from me.

This is not true. We actually love Radio and many think it should've been a single instead of Video Phone

[Subomie]

Almost done just a bit stuck on Pink. I got Please Don't Leave Me, but not sure which of the rest is the least painful.

[holocene]

Noooooooooooooo not Fearlesss Why

[Vilppu]

Originally posted by Subomie

Almost done just a bit stuck on Pink. I got Please Don't Leave Me, but not sure which of the rest is the least painful.

One Foot Wrong, Ave Mary A and Mean are the best but you will probably hate them so idk.

[holocene]

Do I have to do the pre-rate in order to do the actual rates? I don't know these albums bar 2 + the singles and I don't know if I'll have the time.

[50thStateofMind]

hmmm, I have listened to most of these, so I'll do it.

Y'all better get IASF RIGHT tho...if That's Why You're Beautiful doesn't end up on here over all the SF trash

[Bloomers]

I'll do this even if it means having to listen to pink

Edit: Also, this will be one of the rare times I will be somewhat rooting against Beyoncé.

[wesleywalrus]

Not familiar with Janet or Kylie. Send me a list and I'll submit those.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Prismatic

Welcome to "Golden Year of Pop ▲ The ULTIMATE 2008 Rate"!


2008 was an important year in pop music. Four legendary female artists (Madonna, Mariah, Kylie and Janet) made their return to the music scene. The Pepsi trinity (Britney, Beyoncé and P!nk) also released albums that year and all experienced immense success. Last but not least, we got to meet three fresh faces (Katy, Gaga and Taylor) who brokethrough that year.


Wait, weren't all of these albums been used in previous rates already? Yes, you're right, the four legends' albums were part of the 2008 Is For Legends Rate while the remaining 6 were part of the 2008 Megarate.


To deal with the constant requests of allowing used albums to be rated again, a brand new ATRL rate idea is introudced. In this rate, we will be rating just TEN songs from each album and you will be deciding the ten songs!



THE SONGS





PRE-RATE NOMINATIONS

Please PM me your pre-rate nominations.
You can nominate a minimum of FIVE to a maximum of TEN songs from each album.
You have to submit songs for ALL albums.
You only need to send in the song titles, there is no need to rate each song yet.
The ten songs with the most votes from each album will form the FINAL 100 songs we will be rating.

Deadline for pre-rate voting is October 25, 11pm EDT.


OFFICIAL VOTING

More details later...

Don't care to listen to Pink or Katheryn again, but FYC:

- Fearless, Forever and Always

- Phonography, Kill The Lights, Unusual You, Trouble, Quicksand, Amnesia, Rock Boy, Mannequin

- I Don't Know What It Is, Do It Again, Cherry Bomb, The One, Cosmic, In My Arms

- She's Not Me, Incredible, Beat Goes On

- Cruise Control, 4REAL4REAL, Side Effects, For The Record, Migrate, Thanx for Nothin'

- Can't Be Good, 2Nite, Rock With You, Rollercoaster, LUV, So Much Betta

- Radio, Disappear, Sweet Dreams, Diva, Satellites

Remember - you don't have to choose singles!

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by wesleywalrus

Not familiar with Janet or Kylie. Send me a list and I'll submit those.

Sister ,,, you have enough time to listen to two albums.

[Delilah.]

incredible i swear if that makes it in

its like madonnas worst song ever

and also i realized when i was submitting i had never heard the p!nk album so i just randomly sent 5 songs

[Prismy]

Originally posted by holocene

Do I have to do the pre-rate in order to do the actual rates? I don't know these albums bar 2 + the singles and I don't know if I'll have the time.

No, this is not compulsory. You can still send in your rates after the 100 songs are confirmed without participating in this.

[Aurora]

I've only heard 2/10 albums, but I'll be doing this. Let me start pre-rating.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Delilah.

incredible i swear if that makes it in

its like madonnas worst song ever

and also i realized when i was submitting i had never heard the p!nk album so i just randomly sent 5 songs

Important Q: Which five? Some of them definitely do not deserve a place.

[Dylobs]

Oop. I''ll participate in this I want to participate in the pre rate if i have the time