[jgorny]

Originally posted by Hurem

Sis, pm me pls

Pls PM me too! I would like to know a little more about this.

[Outlaws]

Originally posted by I RUN L.A.

Sooo in Wes Craven's New Nightmare, Heather's babysitter is Emmas mom

OH MY GOD, WHAT.

[Cas]

Originally posted by Teneo

Evidence that shows that Audrey has been involved in ALL the killings, despite Rachel's death not being part of the plan and that's why she's so pissed in those episodes

1: There is like a minisecond shot of Audrey's Brandon James collection in episode 1. A lot of members have pointed that out here. This means that Audrey's involvement in the killings was not a rushed thought about killing Nina and then Piper contacted her. She was already planning the killings with Piper by then. This means that Audrey was already a killer in Episode 1.

2: When the killer told Emma to choose between Riley and Brooke, that only would have worked if BOTH killers were near the potential victims. The killer even said that Emma wouldn't reach the survivor after he killed the other. Piper probably was the one who killed Riley, while Audrey was waiting near Brooke if Emma answered that she wanted Riley alive. This means: she appeared as the killer in Episode 3

3: There was Audrey's DNA all over the mask found in the hospital. This means that she already appeared as the killer by the time Episode 4 ended.

4: Audrey was the one who attacked both Piper (for the alibi) and Will at the factory. This means that she appeared as the killer in Episode 6.

5: We had a scene early on the show in which the group is on gym practice (and it's the ONLY school scene we've got other than Branson's lectures and hall meetings) in which Audrey tackles Will and everyone is surprised about that. Then, in the bowling alley, Will does the same tackle into the killer. This is called foreshadowing writing. This means that she appeared as the killer in Episode 7.

6: The amount of times Piper shows up at the dance party and the amount of times the killer appears on screen does not match up. Audrey had to either tie the sheriff or wound him. This means that Audrey was still a killer by Episode 9.

7: Again, Audrey insisted over and over again that Kieran was the killer at the dance party. The killer's main purpose was to make Emma doubt everyone. Again, this means that Audrey was still a killer by Episode 9.

8: When Audrey and Piper, dressed as ghostface, met at Brooke's party, Piper did not kill her, if Audrey wasn't part of the killings by then, Piper would have killed her because Audrey would be the only person alive that knows the killer's true identity.


I feel like a lot of people are saying that the killer can't be the killer just because they like the character or something. Like, some people are doubting even the obvious hints the show gave about it, (week 1) Piper can't be the killer, she's too sweet, the killer is Brooke's mom! *flashforward* (week 9, one hour before the finale) Piper is OBVIOUSLY the killer you heard it here first!!!!! teas

All of this.

[Sam96]

Originally posted by Teneo

I just learned through a contact about the initial storyline for the show and let me just say the say that they changed who the killer/s were VERY late into the show.

sis pm me! Please

[Blatboy]

Originally posted by Sam96

sis pm me! Please

Yes me too please!

[SupahBass05]

Originally posted by Teneo

I just learned through a contact about the initial storyline for the show and let me just say the say that they changed who the killer/s were VERY late into the show.

Wait now I wanna know Link some interviews.

[Ethereal]

Originally posted by Teneo

I'm not going to say anything about the original plan for the show because the changes were made when the writers knew for sure the show would get renewed for a second season. If you have watched the finale and have read some producers interviews: I suspect the original killer/s will be the killers next season if they follow what they wanted to do early with the show, so I'm not going to spoil that .

sis pm me please

[Sam96]

@Teneo please PM me

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by CHERLLOYD

They should have killed Emma off in the season finale that would have been a huge shock as the main girl never dies!! Then Legend B(rooke) could become the main girl of season 2

Nah. Brooke can't be taken seriously as a main girl. Her character was designed for side kick.

She needs to die in the 3rd or 4th episode of season 2. The impact she's made warrants it tbh.

I know it won't happen because they've set her up to be the show's Gale of sorts. She would've died in the freezer scene if they wanted her out, and I don't think they'll quickly develop a secondary female next season to replace her.

[Six]

PM ME SIIISSSS

[ivi]

finally watched the finale over the weekend, i actually really loved the finale.

everyone screaming that the reveal was predictable but of course it's gonna be when we had 10 weeks to figure it out also i'm very happy it was not a new person we never met or someone that made NO sense.

about the sherrif video, i don't even know if it was a live streaming you know, when the killer appeared doesn't mean he/she appeared in that second really there, maybe they just streamed it then.

anyway i think that audrey was the mastermind, as much as it hurts me.

i mean she had a good enough reason to get back at nina and the whole gang, she could have easily swayed piper to kill all these people to hurt emma, but it was to get revenge for herself.

i mean the sd card, the "unkkown caller" id when she called emma from the sherrif station, the dna on the mask........and audrey probably had to make sure to keep everyone at the pool house so piper could kill emma and her mother. she and piper agreed that piper would hit / attack her, so her "what are you waiting for" makes sense.

she maybe then betrayed piper or just wanted to check, whatever.

it's going to be intersting to find out what piper and audrey had been talking for 2 years via mail though, who started it etc. piper arrived as a psycho and when the whole audrey tape leak happend she snatched and told piper to go along with the plan.


howevery it will turn out, i'm excited where this show will go.

also can we agree that brooke is the best girl on the show? here for emma dying in s2 and brooke taking over

[Ethereal]

I actually love Emma. The actress is very pretty and she's very able too...

I don't get the over the top fascination with Brooke but she is a pretty great character.

[ivi]

It's just that Brooke had a character transformation while Emma pretty much stayed the same imo.

[Cas]

Originally posted by ivi

It's just that Brooke had a character transformation while Emma pretty much stayed the same imo.

I completely agree.

[aayAlex]

Brooke is one of the weakest actress on the show.

Bitch can't run and scream to save her life.

[halcyonday]

Brooke is way better than Emma.

[that G.U.Y.]

#Justice4Riley

#Justice4NoahsVirgintiy

[Outlaws]

Originally posted by halcyonday

Brooke is way better than Emma.

I love both of them.

[Instant]

Brooke is amazing and the girl who plays her is good. Every critic agrees on her and Bex Taylor-Klaus being only good actresses of the show. Nina, Riley and Emma def didn't provide better chase scenes than her. It's not like it's Brooke's fault that writers give her such sloppy chase scenes

[Ethereal]

Originally posted by Instant

Brooke is amazing and the girl who plays her is good. Every critic agrees on her and Bex Taylor-Klaus being only good actresses of the show. Nina, Riley and Emma def didnt' provide better chase scenes than her. It's not like it's Brooke's fault that writers give her such sloppy chase scenes

Who are these critics?

Willa Fitz's BA in Acting from Yale probably means more than what those critics have said about Brooke