[M.R.]

Originally posted by Badger

I am calm Anyway I wonder how the era would've fared if MTN was the lead.

MTN is her best single. She missed the opportunity to make it a career-defining song.

[slobro]

I remember I loved the instrumental MTN snippet and was so disappointed when I heard the full MTN, it was so monotonous and not catchy. I like it a lot now but it would've done worse than BTW as the lead.

TEOG should've been the lead single

[Skywalker]

Iggy's upcoming SMASH.

[Nialler]

The production of the demo is so much better than the original
(the lyrics before 7 other writers worked on the song though )

[FreeBitch]

Gaga her next era will be ...

[Duca]

The Telephone video was kind of weird but not weird enough to throw many people off.

The Alejandro video did the trick.

[Vin]

Originally posted by Marvin

Not you bringing this to SYG

BTW, Ciara and Future were dating for a year before they got engaged; that's not "quickly." Know your facts, Vin.

I had to bring it into SYG. It was off-topic and I have 9 points.



And getting engaged after one year is too quick. You can only get engaged after
dating for at least two years. Don't get mad at me, I didn't make the relationship rules.

That's why Ciara ended up alone and with child, in the end. She didn't follow the rules.



...Vin

[Instant]

Originally posted by Nialler

The production of the demo is so much better than the original
(the lyrics before 7 other writers worked on the song though )

Yeah, I liked that production more.

And 7 other writers would've never written such stupid lyrics

[BabyCantYouSee]

Originally posted by Duca

She was at a point where whatever she released as the lead single would have smashed.

Its Hot 100 chart run is hilarious for a 6-week #1: 1-1-1-1-1-1-4-5-5-13-15-16-18-19-24-42-37-49-56-57.

Gaga wasn't no MJ to have that much power. It was a hit because it was a good pop song. Too many ATRL peeps do too much on BTW.

[Kworb]

Originally posted by Meowster

Iggy's upcoming SMASH.

The full version was disappointing, you don't hear her enough.

[Badger]

Originally posted by Meowster

Iggy's upcoming SMASH.

Raptor Badger

[Elusive Chanteuse]

I feel it deep inside,
I feel it come alive,
Here comes that feeling again.
And here it comes...

Mariah's song about penis. <3 <3

[slobro]

The Applause vs 45S thread is a mess

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Edge should have been the lead of BTW

Also did applause actually outsell 45S or are people making that up

[Duca]

Originally posted by slobro

The Applause vs 45S thread is a mess

Originally posted by Matangi

Applause was literally DESIGNED to be a radio hit Listen to its generic, radio friendly production, the chorus etc etc. FFS is the complete opposite.

[Shaliydah88]

Telephone's video wasn't weird. It was actually one of the more normal things Gaga has done.

[Gui Blackout]

Shawn Mendes #1 100-120K

Better than I expected He deserves so much more, so underrated.

[Vin]

Did people actually believe "Edge of Glory" was good? Because the song was awful and dated. Were people pretending to like it because they had to, like the Navy has to pretend to like the #R8 singles, or did everyone genuinely like "Edge of Glory"?

Just wondering.



...Vin

[Thisisit]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFz2rdn2Dnw

What kind of offensive mess

[BabyCantYouSee]

This song is seriously better than every single pop girl song.