The Contenders:
- Katy Perry "Thinking Of You"
- Kelly Clarkson "My Life Would Suck Without You"
- Leona Lewis "I Will Be"
- Taylor Swift "White Horse"
Voted Off:
- David Archuleta "A Little Too Not Over You"
- T.I. f/ Justin Timberlake "Dead And Gone"
- James Morrison f/ Nelly Furtado "Broken Strings"
- The Fray "You Found Me"
- Jason Mraz f/ Colbie Caillat "Lucky"
- My Chemical Romance "Desolation Row"
- Natasha Bedingfield "Soulmate"
- Ne-Yo "Mad"
- Beyonce "Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)"
- Fall Out Boy "I Don't Care"
- Kanye West "Heartless"
- Pink "Please Don't Leave Me"
- The Ting Tings "Be The One"
- The Killers "Spaceman"
- Beyonce "Halo"
- Lily Allen "The Fear"
- Kings Of Leon "Use Somebody"
- The Pussycat Dolls "Bottle Pop"
- Jennifer Hudson "If This Isn't Love"
- Brandy "Long Distance"
- Fall Out Boy "America's Suitehearts"
- Craig David "Insomnia"
- Christina Milian "Us Against The World"
- Akon "Right Now (Na Na Na)"
- Ludacris f/ Chris Brown "What Them Girls Like"
- Britney Spears "Circus" (January 2009 Winner)
Immunity:
- Katy Perry "Thinking Of You"
Vote Off 1, Save 1
Off:
- Taylor Swift "White Horse"
Save:
- Kelly Clarkson "My Life Would Suck Without You"
