ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 10/17/2011
Posts: 20,487
|
Power Housemate Game!
Here are the Judges Comments...
johnsuxx -
Quote:
|
Dream: wtf is this entry a joke
|
Quote:
|
Allstar: What the **** is this? Girl... I mean, yes, the song choice works. But I need you to tell me WHY it works. I'm not gonna do that work for you.
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: This entry is great since it shows Katy has the power to inspire the handicapped
|
Cristhian -
Quote:
|
Dream: cute. express yourself is all about empowerment and i liked that they reflected it back to big bro.
|
Quote:
|
Allstar: I liked it. You had a clear structure and thanks to the questions you were asking yourself in your entry it was easy to follow why you chose that song and most importantly, why you think it fit the theme AND the game.
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: Good song choice, Madonna oozes power. Wasn't totally sold on the explanation but it's passable. It was a bit extra though.
|
FunkyDinevo -
Quote:
|
Dream: good analysis of the lyrics.
|
Quote:
|
Allstar: Perfect. Not only does this song completely fit the theme of "POWER" it also totally fits into this competition. A very creative choice!
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: An original song choice is good I guess. Maybe going a bit too literal though?
|
Slayley -
Quote:
|
Dream: beyonce and this song sucks. btw the song is all about partying. "don't drop that alcohol" as in let's drink all of it, not don't drink. nice try.
|
Quote:
Allstar: Do you honestly believe yourself that 7/11 is about the power alcohol can have over you? And with that video? If anything it's about letting go of your inhibitions and be careless.
I mean I don't want to tell you how to interpret a song so if you believe it's about the power of substance abuse that's nice for you. But I just don't, sorry.
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: Appreciate the attempt at a funny entry but it didn't really make laugh. At least Roar was a fitting song. This isn't.
|
DOMINO -
Quote:
|
Dream: alright this song is all about power that women should have. it's a bit of an obvious choice but whatever.
|
Quote:
|
Allstar: No, I don't like 'Run The World'. But yes, it's a much better example of a song about power than 7/11 was. You seem to have understood its message and explained well enough why it fits. I appreciate that you didn't just leave it at the basic description of a "female empowerment"-song but tried to add some thematical variety into the song's meaning.
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: Safe choice, but the short and sweet explanations were what I was looking for.
|
jax. -
Quote:
|
Dream: so much redundancy. doesn't actually tell me how the song represents power.
|
Quote:
|
Allstar: LOVE this song. What I don't love is your description as to why it fits the theme. The title randomly correlating to it isn't enough for me.Yes, the song's production has power over you but you could say that about every song. I would have liked to see you give one or two examples about its message or refer to its lyrics for me to be truly convinced..
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: Maybe too literal again, but that looks like what you were going for. Very to the point too. Great entry.
|
OhRly? -
Quote:
|
Dream: i really like this one. nice job connecting it to yourself.
|
Quote:
|
Allstar: It works. I like that you define the song's theme of inner strength and overcoming obstacles as self-power. I also enjoyed how you linked it to yourself and your role in the game. I don't think the song completely fits the theme but your entry balanced that out well enough for me.
|
Quote:
|
Subomie: Good for an original take on the idea of power, the explanation didn't sell it as well though
|
- Big Brother
|
|
|
|
