[Scorpio]

Dylan I think you accidentally messed up last round's results.

http://atrl.net/?p=24769586

And no matter what you say, Anna. All I Have is one of her worst videos. It has no replay value, no impact, no nothing. The criteria for judging this round were:

The judges are not going to be giving you a low score just because you don't pick our personal favorite/least favorite video. You just need to make sure the video you choose for each spectrum is in the top/bottom tier of their videography in order to receive a decent score.

Some of these girls have way more videos than others which will definitely be taken into consideration when judging.

You have definitely overlooked this part, Anna. You did not give me an extra point for the fact that J.Lo has so many videos.
And yeah, maybe Papi wasn't the best decision, but just because you think that All I Have is a good video doesn't make it one point worthy.

But okay. I'll live with it. Just want to make sure that judges actually judge by the criteria that they present to us in the challenge description.

Thanks.

[Ronaldista]

Originally posted by DOMINO

Dylan I think you accidentally messed up last round's results.

http://atrl.net/?p=24769586

And no matter what you say, Anna. All I Have is one of her worst videos. It has no replay value, no impact, no nothing. The criteria for judging this round were:



You have definitely overlooked this part, Anna. You did not give me an extra point for the fact that J.Lo has so many videos.
And yeah, maybe Papi wasn't the best decision, but just because you think that All I Have is a good video doesn't make it one point worthy.

But okay. I'll live with it. Just want to make sure that judges actually judge by the criteria that they present to us in the challenge description.

Thanks.

Where does it say I have to give an extra point if someone has a big videography? If anything that means I should be more strict because it gives you a lot of options to choose from and it's easier to find bad and good ones within a range of videos. You said you watched all her videos so there was no reason why you couldn't have found the right choices. All I Have is not one of her worst videos, pretty much any of the generic vids she has released in the last few years is worse.

[Scorpio]

Originally posted by borntodie

Where does it say I have to give an extra point if someone has a big videography? If anything that means I should be more strict because it gives you a lot of options to choose from and it's easier to find bad and good ones within a range of videos. You said you watched all her videos so there was no reason why you couldn't have found the right choices. All I Have is not one of her worst videos, pretty much any of the generic vids she has released in the last few years is worse.

That's not how Dylan meant it, though. Having more videos = more work for me, more time consuming. And on top of that you want to be more strict?

Bye.

And PS: LYLALS is not Selena's worst video. Another example where you went with your taste and not with the criteria.

[Ronaldista]

Originally posted by DOMINO

That's not how Dylan meant it, though. Having more videos = more work for me, more time consuming. And on top of that you want to be more strict?

Bye.

And PS: LYLALS is not Selena's worst video. Another example where you went with your taste and not with the criteria.

Did you ask him? He didn't tell me there was anything wrong with my judging this round so I am sure it was acceptable for him. This round is time consuming for everyone, I have to watch all the videos and at least part of the videographies, too.

So what do you think is worse? I know quite a few other people who think LYLALS is her worst, and Dylan said it in his comment, too. The video has bad effects, is way too overloaded with different scenes/ideas and just doesn't make sense overall. That's pretty bad imo. There is always going to be a subjective element, because there is no list of universally recognised best and worst videos of every artist.

Just accept that I didn't like your choices this round and move on. Next round could be the complete opposite.

[Scorpio]

Originally posted by borntodie

Did you ask him? He didn't tell me there was anything wrong with my judging this round so I am sure it was acceptable for him. This round is time consuming for everyone, I have to watch all the videos and at least part of the videographies, too.

So what do you think is worse? I know quite a few other people who think LYLALS is her worst, and Dylan said it in his comment, too. The video has bad effects, is way too overloaded with different scenes/ideas and just doesn't make sense overall. That's pretty bad imo. There is always going to be a subjective element, because there is no list of universally recognised best and worst videos of every artist.

Just accept that I didn't like your choices this round and move on. Next round could be the complete opposite.

It's okay Énna. Still love ya. I'm just a bit mad because I was so hesitant to send any J.Lo video.
Back then I liked them, but now they all seem so dated. As soon as I saw that I got Jennifer I was like okay, let me go cry.

[K$Ellie]

Originally posted by borntodie

your attitude learn to accept people have different opinions and take your hate for me elsewhere.

if she has something worse it means your choice wasn't the right one. I could have lived with it if there had been something bad about this video still, but there is nothing to criticize. I just didn't understand why you chose it.

I don't hate you I just don't think I deserved a 1 because Really Don't Care is a bad video. You gave someone a 1 just because they didn't send LYLALS which isn't that bad because the bridge is amazing.

[Superiore]

nn the Selena backlash is réal!

[prézli]

Thanks for the 10/10, Dylan

[prézli]

Ethan - Hello Kitty - 3.5
Avril's videography is largely boring because she never looks enthusiastic, so I actually enjoyed Hello Kitty more than many of the others. It's not a good video, but considering she has a video with Chad Kroeger in it, it's not her worst.

[UFO]

So just because I didn't submit the entries you would've liked, I'm given the lowest score possible? Pisstake

[Scorpio]

Anna keeps dragging our averages downE.

[Superiore]

Originally posted by DOMINO

Anna keeps dragging our averages downE.

She should listen to her faves' words more carefully

[Scorpio]

Originally posted by Superiore

She should listen to her faves' words more carefully

I really liked her on Les ATRLers.

[Lucky#17]

Werk Bonbondi.


EDIT: Omg I forgot we switched tribes.

[Remmy]

Originally posted by Lucky#17

Werk Bonbondi.


EDIT: Omg I forgot we switched tribes.

[Remmy]

Ugh this is so sad. This is only the 2nd time out of 8 rounds that I've been in danger. So unfortunate that we have to lose someone from our new team.

[Gabe²]

Originally posted by Remmy

Ugh this is so sad. This is only the 2nd time out of 8 rounds that I've been in danger. So unfortunate that we have to lose someone from our new team.

goodbye Rem , you won't be missed

[Superiore]

Originally posted by Lucky#17

Werk Bonbondi.


EDIT: Omg I forgot we switched tribes.

Lucky

[Remmy]

Originally posted by Gabegabe

goodbye Rem , you won't be missed

Ha ha. I'm laughing so hard.

[Gabe²]

Originally posted by Remmy

Ha ha. I'm laughing so hard.

So am I!