To be considered as a catalog song/album, song/album must be 2 years old. (For Billboard Catalog Albums chart, album must be 2 years old to chart, so I used that)
Britney:
Single - Toxic
Album - Greatest Hits: My Prerogative
Avril:
Singles - Complicated/Sk8er Boi
Album - Let Go
Demi's Don't Forget hadn't even sold 500k when it left the chart, and now it's at 1,031,000.
Here We Go Again (album) had sold 360k in its final charting week in the BB200, and is now at 496k.
Demi's Don't Forget hadn't even sold 500k when it left the chart, and now it's at 1,031,000.
Here We Go Again (album) had sold 360k in its final charting week in the BB200, and is now at 496k.
More importantly Fight For This Love and 3 Words are Cheryl's catalog sellers
Always Be My Baby is definitely her most recurrent hit. Or Fantasy. Album is definitely Greatest Hits even though I think it should be #1s