[BTrisc]

Maybe she meant B+? B and C are quite close on the keyboard.

[Bang Up]

Maybe she meant A+ and had a seizure?

[Skywalker]

Oh well. It's still higher than Artpop and most other pop artists. I have a feeling the allmusic and Chicago Tribune won't be added. It's been forever since they were recorded. Hopefully Metacritic has moved on from the album, thinking this little jazz album has enough reviews for its niche.

[katyperryismylife]

There are really no gimmicks here: no synth beats, no club-ready hits, and no incendiary religious imagery, just two artists taking their craft back to its bones and clearly having a lot of fun in the process.

Well no ****.

[Skywalker]

Originally posted by katyperryismylife

Well no ****.

Imagine a jazz standards album like that though.

[mariska]

There's literally nothing bad said about the album and it's rated as a C+???

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Acceptance is the key to be, to be truly free

[biotin223]

She goes solo on “Lush Life” and predictably kills it, every word dripping with passion, regret, and vulnerability. You remember why she sells out stadiums and inspires legions of dedicated fans, but at the same time, you’ve never been more aware that the meat dress hides a beating heart.

C+

[Skywalker]

I'm beginning to think the score assigners are from different people all together.

[BORNTOSLAY]

A C+ you said?

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by Meowster

I'm beginning to think the score assigners are from different people all together.

Especially the mess that is Kenneth not knowing the score he assigned.

[Alchemist]

These critics are on crack

[Remixed]

ddd bye at consequence of sound

Essential Tracks: “Jewels N’ Drugs”, “ARTPOP”

[Alchemist]

Originally posted by Remixed

Y'all should be e-mailing about that Chicago Tribune review getting added. [email protected]

I e-mailed them about Billboard's BTW review and it got added. (score unchanged though )

The reviews date is listed as Sept. 25, 2014

[Haus]

That review is NOT a C+, good lord

The critics are trolling her hardcore

[suburbannature]

This thread.

It's like a showcase for why Little Monsters have the reputation that they do.

You guys realize that every album has a bunch of positive reviews from blogs that aren't counted, right? Look at My Everything's critical review thread. And I cannot at the stan goggles when reacting to every negative review. Attacking critics? Trying to discredit reviews to raise a MetaCritic score ("like with Born This Way")? That's just not how you treat people who are doing their job and giving fair reviews.

[Dark_Lorde]

Originally posted by suburbannature

This thread.

It's like a showcase for why Little Monsters have the reputation that they do.

You guys realize that every album has a bunch of positive reviews from blogs that aren't counted, right? Look at My Everything's critical review thread. And I cannot at the stan goggles when reacting to every negative review. Attacking critics? Trying to discredit reviews to raise a MetaCritic score ("like with Born This Way")? That's just not how you treat people who are doing their job and giving fair reviews.

.

[Skywalker]

Originally posted by suburbannature

This thread.

It's like a showcase for why Little Monsters have the reputation that they do.

You guys realize that every album has a bunch of positive reviews from blogs that aren't counted, right? Look at My Everything's critical review thread. And I cannot at the stan goggles when reacting to every negative review. Attacking critics? Trying to discredit reviews to raise a MetaCritic score ("like with Born This Way")? That's just not how you treat people who are doing their job and giving fair reviews.

[MadMagical]

Originally posted by suburbannature

This thread.

It's like a showcase for why Little Monsters have the reputation that they do.

You guys realize that every album has a bunch of positive reviews from blogs that aren't counted, right? Look at My Everything's critical review thread. And I cannot at the stan goggles when reacting to every negative review. Attacking critics? Trying to discredit reviews to raise a MetaCritic score ("like with Born This Way")? That's just not how you treat people who are doing their job and giving fair reviews.

The lowest score, from Slant, is not fair at all. The author of the post constantly wrote articles bashing Gaga in the past. They do have a reason to ask why this was one of the few reviews counting towards the metacritic score.

[Dark_Lorde]

Originally posted by Meowster

It's true tho. I actually really like the album as you know.

But there's people on this thread in plain black and white that have asked people to write in and complain about the people that have given negative reviews. You can see the campaigns to try and get a review not counted or for someone to lose their job.

The person that posted that paragraph has a valid point. Obviously not all of you. You're great, others are great but there is that element to this thread.