[dcode78]

Originally posted by AHemsworth

I'm so tried of this Rih bv. Bey mess.

When time comes and clocks with receipts. Both ends are delusional.

[Karrueche Tran]

Originally posted by Legacy

The fact that people are comparing Beyoncé and Rihanna when the first debuted way before the other means a lot tbh.

Like Madonna and Gaga comparisons

Beyoncé is the Madonna of this generation while Rihanna is the Gaga one

[RainDreamer]

I would never say so, she's one off yes but its impossible for anyone including forbes to truly eveluate how big a star is .

[Lein]

Originally posted by Karrueche Tran

Like Madonna and Gaga comparisons

Beyoncé is the Madonna of this generation while Rihanna is the Gaga one

[dcode78]

Originally posted by Legacy

The fact that people are comparing Beyoncé and Rihanna when the first debuted way before the other means a lot tbh.

Like for real. Beyonce has damn near ten years on Rih in the entertainment industry.

Not surprised one bit at the hypocrisy or the misinformed individuals in this thread.

[PrettyHurts]

Originally posted by QueenBLadyG

Forbes uses more than just earnings to rank stars on their list, try again.

And a portion of what ever Rih earns goes to supplying Blue's nursery. Rih isn't more powerful than Bey, when Blue is collecting checks from Auntie Riri.

You did not go there sis

[idkher]

Originally posted by Karrueche Tran

and? Bey first tour did 90m, the 2nd 120m and the 3rd 229m, this is what a touring artist is

How can Rihanna be an album artist if she barely sells more than 1.8m albums per year? she can't sell album (only discounted and in black friday week) and she cant make more than 200k of people to buy her album in the debut week. and please don't talk about gggb when it had a re-release, tons of promos and discounts.

Lmao almost everything in this post is a lie :/

[Lein]

Also Adele says hi, as income has only music does make her "smaller"

[Legacy]

Originally posted by Karrueche Tran

Like Madonna and Gaga comparisons

Beyoncé is the Madonna of this generation while Rihanna is the Gaga one

Not you bringing Madonna/Gaga

Originally posted by Lein

Also Adele says hi, as income has only music does make her "smaller"

[Lyrical.]

Without a doubt.

[Terylee]

Originally posted by Mystic Boy

Oh really? And those 1000 singers out there grossed over 230 millions dollars with their tour? :')

Sorry, I was talking about my country. I wanted to add that. But yeah she's just one of many female singers here in Germany. She never got the love and hype Britney got 1999-2001 or Gaga in 2009 or Rihanna when she releases something. She is just there but nothing special.

[Alejandrawrrr]

Originally posted by dcode78

Like for real. Beyonce has damn near ten years on Rih in the entertainment industry.

Not surprised one bit at the hypocrisy or the misinformed individuals in this thread.

The way every stanbase selectively chooses years to try and make your faves look better in comparison to Beyonce According to ATRL, Destiny's Child doesn't exist, Beyonce debuted in 2003, which is a mere 2 years before Rih (again, according to the rules ya'll set forth in every other thread), and Rihanna has 2 (soon to be three ) MORE albums than Beyonce (thus an advantage in overall albums sold AND singles), yet she's still lower in album sales by a few mill , and has like 1 less world tour?

Unless you want to include those "damn near ten years", in which case Rihanna falls considerably behind in album sales (with only two, soon to be one less studio album) and the gap in #1 singles is closed by quite a bit

[Jicky]

Yes for now but wait until Kelly Rowland releases next.

[6_INCH_HEELS]

Originally posted by Alejandrawrrr

The way every stanbase selectively chooses years to try and make your faves look better in comparison to Beyonce According to ATRL, Destiny's Child doesn't exist, Beyonce debuted in 2003, which is a mere 2 years before Rih (again, according to the rules ya'll set forth in every other thread), and Rihanna has 2 (soon to be three ) MORE albums than Beyonce (thus an advantage in overall albums sold AND singles), yet she's still lower in album sales by a few mill , and has like 1 less world tour?

Unless you want to include those "damn near ten years", in which case Rihanna falls considerably behind in album sales (with only one less) and the gap in #1s is closed by quite a bit

I will come in a give a quick SCALP! for this post. Y'all can not keep saying Bey has been around longer in terms of her receipts and impact but then turn around and disassociate DC's success from hers when it's convenient for you. No matter how you add it up, she still comes out on top.

[PrettyHurts]

Originally posted by Alejandrawrrr

The way every stanbase selectively chooses years to try and make your faves look better in comparison to Beyonce According to ATRL, Destiny's Child doesn't exist, Beyonce debuted in 2003, which is a mere 2 years before Rih (again, according to the rules ya'll set forth in every other thread), and Rihanna has 2 (soon to be three ) MORE albums than Beyonce (thus an advantage in overall albums sold AND singles), yet she's still lower in album sales by a few mill , and has like 1 less world tour?

Unless you want to include those "damn near ten years", in which case Rihanna falls considerably behind in album sales (with only two, soon to be one less studio album) and the gap in #1 singles is closed by quite a bit

you betta add in them DC receipts, she wrote and sung those hymns...hmph

[B-Luke]

In the US maybe. Everywhere else the likes of Rihanna, P!nk, Lana, etc. are currently bigger.

[Androo]

YES she is and im a huge KATYCAT !

[idkher]

Originally posted by Alejandrawrrr

The way every stanbase selectively chooses years to try and make your faves look better in comparison to Beyonce According to ATRL, Destiny's Child doesn't exist, Beyonce debuted in 2003, which is a mere 2 years before Rih (again, according to the rules ya'll set forth in every other thread), and Rihanna has 2 (soon to be three ) MORE albums than Beyonce (thus an advantage in overall albums sold AND singles), yet she's still lower in album sales by a few mill , and has like 1 less world tour?

Unless you want to include those "damn near ten years", in which case Rihanna falls considerably behind in album sales (with only two, soon to be one less studio album) and the gap in #1 singles is closed by quite a bit

In this context it makes sense to include her time in DC because she has been a star for a lot longer than Rihanna. When talking about chart stats it makes no sense to include DC because that is a completely different act than Beyonce, like seriously it's not hard to understand

[BrooklynBoy]

Yes! My stanbases better snatch & drag! Like last night never happened. Proud of y'all

[PrettyHurts]

Originally posted by idkher

In this context it makes sense to include her time in DC because she has been a star for a lot longer than Rihanna. When talking about chart stats it makes no sense to include DC because that is a completely different act than Beyonce, like seriously it's not hard to understand

But why do collaborations count but not DC....especially if Beyoncé sang 90% of the song........