[Shinning]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/...-sasha-fierce/

5.7

She has come so far.

[Pop pop123]

I hope Pitchfork give Mariah BNA just like how the they gave #B BNT <3

(The only pop girl / guy artist? to receive the honor)

[Cap10Planet]

I Am... deserved lower.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

P4K is a lame website that is held to too much of a high standard.

I think they often bring an interesting/needed perspective to the critical landscape and find myself enjoying many of their write-ups, but the way their acolytes give deference to them as a sort of shortcut to understanding/legitimacy can be cringe-inducing.

[Dollas n Diamonds]

[Reader]

Originally posted by Chemical X.

Feedback by Impactnet has officially made it onto my study playlist. Help me raise these grades, queen!

I remember terrorising my neighbours with stanning down for Feedback for a whole summer.

[Jameson Teqkilla]

I doubt Nicki's single will be able to match the masterpiece that is YASSS BISH!

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

I think they often bring an interesting/needed perspective to the critical landscape and find myself enjoying many of their write-ups, but the way their acolytes give deference to them as a sort of shortcut to understanding/legitimacy can be cringe-worthy.

You should see the comments on Last.fm by hipster hip hop fans every time a hip hop album drops

[Jameson Teqkilla]

Fantano stans are even more annoying than P4k stans.

[Shinning]

Wait at the B'Day praise on that IASF review!
This is why I **** with them!

[boodytay]

Originally posted by Reader

Taylor's so boring and no-one cares about her so Pitchfork can stay paying her dust.

The 7-time Grammy winner, 27-million album seller, 89 million-digital tracks seller and critically-acclaimed singer-songwriter remains unbothered.

[Taste of Honey]

Moo is actually kinda slaying me. Who would've thought?

[Chemical X.]

The fact that "I Am... Sasha Fierce" won six ****ing grammys and B'Day only got one

[Cap10Planet]

Let me not do too much to P4K because they gave Kaleidoscope Dream a high score and Best New Music.

[Kworb]

Mariah is bringing the Memoirs level slayage so far. She's still at her peak.

[Shinning]

The Unapologetic P4K review is still just

[Vin]

So, shall we go through all of the recent fads?

• Carly Rae Jepsen
• LMFAO
• Iggy Azalea
• Adele
• Lorde
• Imagine Dragons
• Miley Cyrus
• Far East Movement
• Ariana Grande
• Florida Georgia Line

Just to name a few.



...Vin

[boodytay]

THE PITCHFORK REVIEW FOR WHO YOU ARE. SCREAAAAAMMMMING.

[RihannasVeryOwn]

Ariana Grande is not a fad. She's a critic darling (her debut got 81 on MC), she's beautiful, talented and interesting enough to go far.
She's just having her GGGB phase right now, starting with her Umbrella (although Problem has a superior feature)

[Jameson Teqkilla]

Originally posted by Shinning

The Unapologetic P4K review is still just

She's frozen in a relationship with a bad person and tangled in a toxic situation that feels out of her control (SOUNDS FUN, RIRI!)-- themes that are mirrored in Unapologetic's surplus of minor-key treacle.