Quote:
Originally posted by atrlster
Where is this disdain? All I'm trying to say here is that a change this minor doesn't usually warrant credit.
And small melodic changes should be recognized but this small? 
Like I said above, many artists add runs and other minor additions to their songs all the time differing from demos and don't claim credit for it. If someone holds a note in a song slightly longer than the demo, no one is going to claim credit  But who knows, maybe you think Beyonce should claim credit if she did that.
String arrangements and guitar parts are added to song all the time and often they can lean melodic. Do you think most people are getting songwriting credit for that? |
small or big, that is up to the writer/producer to decide, not to you.
and you do know that people actually get writing credit for some part of beat, drum pattern or things that don't relate to melody?
also what you said about runs, adlips are vocal producing. and those artists don't do that.
only few in the industry do vocal producing. lol
usually main producer do that, but there're even job as 'vocal producer'
this is different case. and ryan tedder said all the thing you should know.
"beyonce got credit for those thing and she deserve it".
.