Melted isn't even the best song on Play, Artificial Grass is.
And for the record, I don't think there's anything wrong with
wanting an artist you like to be on top and being disappointed at a different turn-out. If SHINee were snubbed of #1 I'd be disappointed, but it wouldn't have my judgement of the music.

I think most fans can say they love/want to see to see their favourite artist on top, it's a nice thing.