[Great Username]

Not at that sig. An obsessed mess. Red its power.

[thediscomonkey]

What power?

[TaylorFantasy]

nnnnn queen disco slay

[Great Username]

"Factually, Speak Now & Red sold almost the same amount."

A true fictious mess. Not in the US and certainly not WW. Max Martin's omnipotence. The fact that nobody remembers Speak Now and Lord looks back on it feeling ashamed at its locality and lack of impact.

[TaylorFantasy]

Originally posted by Great Username

"Factually, Speak Now & Red sold almost the same amount."

A true fictious mess. Not in the US and certainly not WW. Max Martin's omnipotence. The fact that nobody remembers Speak Now and Lord looks back on it feeling ashamed at its locality and lack of impact.

But none were contributed by King Great Username A true stan tbh

[Great Username]

Originally posted by TaylorFantasy

But none were contributed by King Great Username A true stan tbh

Right? Who else?

[thediscomonkey]

Without massive smash singles, it hit 4M in US, it did pretty good as well WW. Question is how come with those smashes, why Dead is still far behind Flawless?

[Great Username]

Yes at you leaving Speak Now in the dust due to its lack of receipts and moving on to Flawless.

[holyground]

Oh I didn't realise the Red vs Speak Now war is still on

I'm quite sure most here chooses Speak Now over Red so GU can sit

[thediscomonkey]

Without massive smash singles, it hit 4M in US, it did pretty good as well WW.

But....

[thediscomonkey]

I just do not want to miss the party.

Originally posted by nicedude

IKYWT's wig is not safe.
Dark Horse is alREDy up to 121M AI in POP while IKYWT's record is @ 126M AI?

Isn't this record just as useless as the biggest digital seller thing?

[Great Username]

Originally posted by thediscomonkey

But....

The self-drag. Not at selling less than Red and having no hit singles being a receipt.

[Icannot]

Originally posted by Great Username

The self-drag. Not at selling less than Red and having no hit singles being a receipt.

[thediscomonkey]

Originally posted by Great Username

The self-drag. Not at selling less than Red and having no hit singles being a receipt.

Point remains that DER didn't sell as much as expected.

[Great Username]

Originally posted by thediscomonkey

Point remains that DER didn't sell as much as expected.

Oh? I should go back to when WANEGOD and IKYWT were released and expose the album sales predictions?

[thediscomonkey]

Originally posted by Great Username

Oh? I should go back to when WANEGOD and IKYWT were released and expose the album sales predictions?

Those #s would be amazing if we are talking about Katheryn or any other flops. But considering Her status as an anomaly at album sales and Her sales #s with hit singles...... But at the end of the dayy...

[Great Username]

Originally posted by thediscomonkey

Those #s would be amazing if we are talking about Katheryn or any other flops. But considering Her status as an anomaly at album sales and Her sales #s with hit singles...... But at the end of the dayy...

Outsold by 21 and...? The flop pop girls are struggling to reach Red's first week sales yet alone multiplying that by 4.

[anticore]

I thought we're over this discussion about Red vs Speak Now but anyways, then i'm coming with the facts again.

First: Commercial side:

REd's WW sales is higher than Speak Now (Last time i checked Speak Now was around 5.8.M while Red was so close to 6 M)

Red's singles sold rouglhy 3.3M more than Speak Now's singles, (again just a simple clacullation, not the exact number) Divided by 15, so you can see that it's equal to roughly 220k album copies. So in sum, Red sold rougly 400-450k higher than Speak Now as of today.

So, our conclusion is that commercially Red > Speak Now. Fact #1

Wait for the next ones..

[thediscomonkey]

But if She wants Pop, She should snatch T-ARA & Brown Eyed Girls their producers. Truly amazing. Truly unique. That's perfection without being annoying or basic.

And whoever did "SuperB"

Originally posted by Great Username

Outsold by 21 and...? The flop pop girls are struggling to reach Red's first week sales yet alone multiplying that by 4.

True. But how much works and smash singles it took for Der to do it, Preach Now did it so effortlessly.

[Great Username]

Originally posted by thediscomonkey

But if She wants Pop, She should snatch T-ARA & Brown Eyed Girls their producers. Truly amazing. Truly unique. That's perfection without being annoying or basic.

And whoever did "SuperB"



True. But how much works and smash singles it took for Der to do it makes Preach Now did it so effortlessly.

But you are forgetting that Speak Now followed a massive era whereas Red had the burden of following a flop album.