| |
Tournament: I Love Money Season 2 | Recommendations for Season 3
Member Since: 3/14/2013
Posts: 37,294
|
Are you a judge? 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/2/2009
Posts: 18,322
|
Quote:
Originally posted by e437
Are you a judge? |
A guest judge 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 20,010
|
Y'all judges are being too judgy, I'd like to see you guys do the same challenge. It's a bit different when you have to follow the criteria. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/14/2013
Posts: 37,294
|
Quote:
Originally posted by staracademy1990
A guest judge |
We have guest judges?
Anyway, I am worried af 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/2/2009
Posts: 18,322
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Timber
Y'all judges are being too judgy, I'd like to see you guys do the same challenge. It's a bit different when you have to follow the criteria. |
Not being "too judgy", I was part of ANTM and we had the same challenge, the gifs we submitted were much better. This bunch of enteries was just lacking 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 20,010
|
Quote:
Originally posted by staracademy1990
Not being "too judgy", I was part of ANTM and we had the same challenge, the gifs we submitted were much better. This bunch of enteries was just lacking |
Jesus, I can't remember your name.  is it Zayn? I'm sure it starts with a Z.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 20,010
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 21,143
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FunkyDinevo
And that's okay cause I know I'm not the worst. Your words don't mean nothing 
|
Sure, Miss Thang.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 10/17/2011
Posts: 20,487
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Timber
Y'all judges are being too judgy, I'd like to see you guys do the same challenge. It's a bit different when you have to follow the criteria. |
We've all done this challenge before in different games and we've all been successful in different games, that's why we're judges.  In fact me and Nicki won this same gif challenge last year.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 21,866
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Citrus
|
I see you
And mess @ me having some voodoo curse. I always find a better entry after submitting
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2011
Posts: 30,381
|
Ok the library closed, I was doing some filming today...since Zaid submitted stuff, I'm gonna do some calculations again
PS. I'm in a mcdonalds parking lot borrowing their internet
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 21,866
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Zune
Ok the library closed, I was doing some filming today...since Zaid submitted stuff, I'm gonna do some calculations again
PS. I'm in a mcdonalds parking lot borrowing their internet |
The struggle
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/22/2012
Posts: 40,939
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2011
Posts: 30,381
|
I Love Money Challenge 2: The Judges Comments
Alrighty this was a very elaborate judging process if i can say so myself. We have a special judge if you don't already know
Staracademy1990 aka Zaid
He was a judge from last season of ILM and I wanted to give him a chance to do a judging at least once in this season. So I'm glad some of y'all got accompanied with him already
Now onto the judges comments:
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Cupid
Hugamari -
This is the second time you've failed to submit and i'm pretty sure all you've posted in the thread in between challenges is "ratchet" .... I love you gurl but ratchet indeed. Why bother to sign up.. 0/10
TheSeenScene -
You had time to sit in the tinychat but not submit? Ok girl. 0/10
ririfan21 -
I'm not sure if Zune is aware but riri actually posted on my wall saying he wanted to quit the game, I feel like maybe he sent in multiple gifs on purpose so he would get eliminated. I'm gonna miss my baby  0/10
Timber -
I've seen this gif used a few times but it hasn't really been over-used on ATRL.. "3) It makes fun pop culture, which most gis fail to do." I don't agree with this, practically every gif used on ATRL is some sort of jab at pop culture... However I do actually like the gif, I would use it if somebody was talking **** and not making any sense, i'd just post that to make fun of them and how stupid they are. Good effort. 7/10
rl231 -
Well, it's not really original.. It's just another laughing gif... It's a nice laugh though.. 5/10
Citrus -
I can see the effect you were going for with the whole #OOP kinda reaction.. It kind of misses the mark though. It's too subtle it doesn't properly emote what you were going for, sorry. I was expecting something bigger and sassier from you! 6/10
CBXC -
It's ugly and kind of scary, especially for a kids show (which I used to love as a kid). I'd probably use it in an ironic way. 6/10
FunkyDinevo -
I mean it works I guess. I've never normally been a fan of these kind of gifs but I can definitely see how it works and I liked your examples. 7/10
Musickid203 -
Simple but effective, he's cute too. 6/10
CrazyCat -
What is this and what is it doing here? Honey no. 5/10
Nasiir15 -
It's ugly but I can't stop staring at it in a creepy way. It's effective too for it's purpose. 7/10
e437 -
What is this and what is it doing here? I literally get nothing from this gif, I just really don't understand... 4/10
richa07 -
For a second I thought riri sent in this. Um, I do enjoy a good Nicki gif, I like this one because it basically the face i'm making whilst judging these entries. Your examples were awful though. 6.5/10
Starships -
Well you surprised me. I love it. Her face, the eyebrows, the smile, first time I saw this gif I cackled. Good job (stop being messy in ATRL HQ, I saw you nearly get banned ) 8.5/10
Jax -
She looks like the maid from family guy fffff. It's cute, it works, I could see it having a short-shelf life on ATRL. 7/10
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by ethan
ririfan21: 0.00000000009
In future rounds, let's try to make sure we:
a) read the instructions and do the challenge correctly
b) provide more original entries that actually show your personality
Timber: 6.392485713911
I love that gif, but I have definitely seen it around the forum before and used better than the examples you gave.
rl231: 9.12345678999
The fact that Stefon hasn't happened yet on ATRL astounds me, he IS ATRL! Really great idea, some of the examples were perfect and others were alright.
Citrus: 5.66616661666166
I like you man, I wish I could give you a higher score, but this entry didn't do it for me. I like the gif, it's funny, but it's appeal is limited and none of the examples stood out.
CBXC: 10
The only gif that made me laugh out loud. Perfection. I can see that being big in certain sections of ATRL. The entries were standard but the gif makes it all worth it.
FunkyDinevo: 4.18139907389
I'm sorry, I just don't get it. I don't like the gif at all, but talent show gifs are popular so it could take off. The examples were the best part.
Musickid203: 5.0023729923
I can't see myself ever using it, it's not particularly funny. Like Funky, the examples were the most enjoyable part of the entry.
CrazyCat: 6.4
The good part? I could see it being used on ATRL. The bad part? The reason I could see it being used is because we've had 3,000 gifs just like it of people like Hayden Panettiere, Beyonce, and Demi Lovato washing their face. Emma Roberts is Queen and all, but it's not very original.
Nasiir15: 6.489102745555
Is that Zooboomafoo? I like the gif, but I can't see it being used and the examples were subpar. I know you can do better!
e437: 5.00000034
King Collin and all, but he has better gifs. I don't like that one unfortunately. Your examples were not bad, but the gif is just not there for me.
richa70: 7.1839402827
Has ririfan found that gif yet? If not, he will love it when he sees it. I could see the Barbz going HAM on it but it's kind of basic. Not bad though!
Starships: 6.82494929929
The gif is a bit immature, it gives off a childish vibe, so I can't see it being too big of a hit on ATRL. However, it is a funny gif and your examples were good!
Jax: 7.9
Soap opera gifs are hilarious and popular so that was smart! It's a funny gif, the examples were eh, but at least the gif was good. Great job!
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Zune
Hugamari: 0/10
Do you even care to know what score you just got? trust me I've seen you posting in other Games Section threads several times a day, I sent out twice to a select few including you to remind you of the deadline. to seem like your trying for two rounds (seemingly) does not put a good taste in my mouth
TheSeenScene 0/10
This is based off of the no entry. I will say idk what is up (if you were bothered by the bottom 3 last round). Honestly your passion that was brought forward from wanting to be so badly in ILM last season and to see in getting the chance, you have opted out of submitting an entry. I hope you figure your situations out.
ririfan21: 3/10
I have felt to look past you not following the rules of the challenge, but I'll look past that for a moment. In your examples you provided for us, I feel the examples are of lower quality and their seemed to be minimal effort in the final product. I know we convered back and forth the concerns I had about your entry and you did respond at that. You just never got back to me regarding this entry
Timber: 6.01/10
When I did ANTM, i tried so hard to look for an original gif enough to a point where my final gif I submitted was only semi funny. While there is this for your entry, I also ffelt the examples you provided could have eliminated the gif altogether and the conversation would have made little to no difference (as Miley's tongue is really the only thing to look at and is the only unique quality the gif brings to the table).
rl231: 6.2/10
I like the thought of uing one of tthe funnier characters from SNL. Only in knowing the characters context one could get a semi kii from the gif. But honestly for this forum and the sake of what the gif brings to the table, it feels any gif with a celebrity laughing could upstage this charater's laughing
Citrus: 8.2/10
This entry i found really good for clocking fellow posts in ATRL. People see its regarding someone attempting to do a reach or just flat out failing. either way its multifacited and its works
CBXC: 10/10
Now this entry is a great cross between >  and  Which is excellent. A lot of the mood of many ATRL users express this feeling very otfen (as forums like this have many diverse opinions) and often times the dumb things users say will leadd to a gif reacging for something like this
FunkyDinevo: 5.5/10
The gif is someone just singing rather crazily and people on any talent show could look this messy. The examples to me however were simply okay within its context, but nothing really was added with the gif you used.
MusicKid203: 6.9/10
So the gif's you associated with your examples worked decently well I woould say. However I couldn't tell when this would be used considering posting only a gif can get automatically marked as warnable spam. So yeah
CrazyCat: 5.5/10
So what works with this GIF right now is Emma Roberts is currently atrl's shady gif (which atrl goes through minor phases like the Latoya ones that used to pop up more often then not). But its someone wwashing a face with its examples beiing not enough to stay on its own as unique. When Emma become unpopular (or less), so would the usage of her
Nasiir15: 7.1/10
I like the gif you presented. I just wanted this in a less gif spam warnable way'
e437: 8.3/10
Your was pretty well balanced in terms of incorporating your posts and then the gif natrually fitting with the messy examples you posted. Very unique
richa70: 4/10
I felt these examples, but this particular gif Nicki give as a look I find comes up more often then not. I'd assume this one can be left in the dust easily since this look she uses pretty often (and better/shady ones)
Starships: 6.5/10
When I saw these entries, this entry appealed to me since its a very atrl based gif. I saw it had relatie potential. Now while I only saw this unique demi gif used only for Demi related topics, I wish your examples tried to expand my thoughts of where this would fit just to try.
Jax: 9.5/10
some your examples were better then others, but the better ones were perfect situations to use for the GIF. l liked the shocked face and it could be a relative classic because its dramatic and its "shocking" |
Quote:
|
Originally posted by staracademy1990
Comments
ririfan21 - 2/10 - obviously failed to meet the challenge, but the Gaga gif you used could be a hit, so I gave you points for that
Timber - 4/10 - terrible gif, I dislike it on so many levels. I didn’t need you to explain why you chose the gif, and your examples were weak.
rl231 - 6/10 - I don’t like this gif and it won’t become a hit but it works in with the examples given.
Citurs - 6/10 - the examples were pretty bad, gif is alright but won’t go anywhere outside of this thread
CBXC - 4/10 - this is bad on so many levels and that blinding background 
FunkyDinevo - 3/10 - what’s this mess? gave you points for that keri hilson poster, it was funny
Musickid203 - 6/10 - again this isn’t a bad gif but won’t go anywhere
CrazyCat - 7/10 - it’s shady, I like it, but I feel I’ve seen something similar
Nasiir15 - 1/10 - I’m scared, next.
e437 - 2/10 - I don’t know what’s worse the gif or examples
richa70 - 7/10 - probably the gif with most potential but seeing how ririfan21 has already spammed this forum with Nicki gifs, this will prob go no where
Starships - 5/10 - funny gif, but won’t work and your examples were terrible
Jax - 5/10 - okay gif with very limited usage |
And last but not least:
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/14/2013
Posts: 37,294
|
I will listen to Melvin's soon
Aww thanks Zune 
I am still afraid as ****
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/14/2013
Posts: 37,294
|
Awwwwwww thanks to Melvin too
And I agree with the others too
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2011
Posts: 30,381
|
Before I reveal the offical winning team results, based on the judges scores in terms of strict average, the winning team had an overall higher average then the other team. but here's my warning to the the teams. Had I not included the people who did not submit and send it a correct entry, The losing teams average here would have won the challenge over the actual winning team (barely). I would keep this in mind when it comes to future rounds.
Alright with the decent subpar results across the board, we do however have an official winning team. First here are your averages individually:
Judges Average Scores:
Gold Team:
Hugamari: 0/10
NICKIMINAJ: 0
Zune: 0
ethan: 0
Cupid: 0
staracademy1990: 0
TheSeenScene: 0/10
NICKIMINAJ: 0
Zune: 0
ethan: 0
Cupid: 0
staracademy1990: 0
Timber: 5.586971/10
NICKIMINAJ: 4
Zune: 6.01
ethan: 6.924857
Cupid: 7
staracademy1990: 4
Citrus: 6.573233/10
NICKIMINAJ: 7
Zune: 8.2
ethan: 5.666167
Cupid: 6
staracademy1990: 6
CBXC: 8/10
NICKIMINAJ: 10
Zune: 10
ethan: 10
Cupid: 6
staracademy1990: 4
CrazyCat: 5.96/10
NICKIMINAJ: 5.9
Zune: 5.5
ethan: 6.4
Cupid: 5
staracademy1990: 7
Starships: 6.36499/10
NICKIMINAJ: 5
Zune: 6.5
ethan: 6.824949
Cupid: 8.5
staracademy1990: 5
Green Team
Jax: 7.28/10
NICKIMINAJ: 7
Zune: 9.5
ethan: 7.9
Cupid: 7
staracademy1990: 5
rl231: 5.764691/10
NICKIMINAJ: 2.5
Zune: 6.2
ethan: 9.123456
Cupid: 5
staracademy1990: 6
FunkyDinevo: 5.23628/10
NICKIMINAJ: 6.5
Zune: 5.5
ethan: 4.181399
Cupid: 7
staracademy1990: 3
MusicKid203: 5.880475/10
NICKIMINAJ: 5.5
Zune: 6.9
ethan: 5.002373
Cupid: 6
staracademy1990: 6
Nasiir15: 5.517821
NICKIMINAJ: 6
Zune: 7.1
ethan: 6.489103
Cupid: 7
staracademy1990: 1
e437: 5.36/10
NICKIMINAJ: 7.5
Zune: 8.3
ethan: 5
Cupid:4
staracademy1990: 2
richa70: 5.336788/10
NICKIMINAJ: 2
Zune: 4
ethan: 7.18394
Cupid: 6.5
staracademy1990: 7
ririfan21: 1.2/10
NICKIMINAJ: 1
Zune: 3
ethan: 9 x 10-10
Cupid: 0
staracademy1990: 2
Now one team overall had an average of 5.197007 and the other team had an average of 4.640742
So the team with the higher average is:
THE Green Team!!!!!!
Congrats to you Green Team. Also revealed with the results we have a clear Paymaster from the winning team
Jax!!!!
You had the highest average and score of your team so you will be the paymaster
Gold Team it will now be your job to submit a bottom 3 of your team members to be up for elimination. Seeing as this gets tough for y'all as you had an elimination before, this is your duty in the competition to submit a bottom 3 that feel worthy and deserve to be in the bottom 3.
Now the person that does not submit a Bottom 3 by 10 PM EST on New Year's Day (1/1/14), will be automatically entered into the Bottom 3. Good luck y'all and happy new year
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/14/2013
Posts: 37,294
|
There is a God 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 21,866
|
Not me having the 2nd lowest score on my team. Without the no-submitters, I would be the 2nd lowest overall. Damn y'all judges are harsh
But that's okay. At least we still won 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 21,866
|
Bye @ Melvin's video
|
|
|
|
|
|
