Gaga has been commercial while also being kinda experimental before tho, like Poker Face, Bad Romance, Telephone, those song titles aren't generic song titles but they aren't like too unrelatable. And the Paparazzi, Telephone, Bad Romance videos, they aren't her partying in a club, but it isn't like some weird kinda fetish **** gore-extravaganza.
As long as the music is good and the lyrics can be relatable in some way and the videos are moderately artistic/experimental, she'll do fine. Like, it's Gaga. The public will always pick up on Gaga, during her little blackout people from my school tweeted like "Where tf did Gaga go? I miss that crazy bitch" or **** like that. The general public can be easily pleased by a semi-relatable song that is to good music.
Yall have to trust her... And Interscope too, they weren't blind during the BTW era. They have learned from their mistakes.
. The end result will rely on Gaga's theme and music.
And Gaga cashing in on the cup song success.