[toai]

Originally posted by xDiamondx

I see what you did there.

Hello isn't that bad,. It's catchy, but lyrically, it feels counterproductive to the actual sound production.

I'm fine with Einstein being next to drop. The instrumentals are my favorite part of it. Only the beginning verse was great. The rest including Dumb + Dumb = You is awkward at the very least.

Honestly deserves to be in the Top 5 at least. The vocals and the lyrics >>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Taemira]

Impossible needs to be in Top 10!
The lyrics and the emotion always slay me so hard
I gave it a 10 on my new score list but Addicted didn't reflect the new scores

[Heartbeat Song]

Originally posted by lifeofpariah

You Thought Wrong is kind of awful TBH
The lyrics are awful and cheesy
Kelly's voice sounds hollow on verses
And i'm not here for Tamyra's awful witchlike voice

Originally posted by mike_10

Einstein better be next

Finally some taste, I canNOT stand when people praise these songs. They are not worthy of Kelly's talent.... however, I still wouldn't give them a zero.

YTW and Einstein are my 2 lowest songs for the rate.

[rivers]

Originally posted by lifeofpariah

You Thought Wrong is kind of awful TBH
The lyrics are awful and cheesy
Kelly's voice sounds hollow on verses
And i'm not here for Tamyra's awful witchlike voice

I swear some of the adjectives you use to describe Kelly's voice are just

[toai]

Originally posted by ClinicStudent

Finally some taste, I canNOT stand when people praise these songs. They are not worthy of Kelly's talent.... however, I still wouldn't give them a zero.

YTW and Einstein are my 2 lowest songs for the rate.

Kelly obviously trying to send you a message. You thought wrong and Dumb+Dumb=You

[Chivas]

Impossible definitely deserves top 10. What a criminally underrated song.

[joelovesmusic]

Originally posted by Chivas

Impossible definitely deserves top 10. What a criminally underrated song.

"Spoke up and thought I'd try, try to step across the line...".....or is it "Just woke up and thought I'd try"....either way...

Masterpiece!

[Heartbeat Song]

Top 5:
Addicted
You Love Me
Can I Have A Kiss
Maybe
Honestly

[Troye]

Originally posted by toai

Originally posted by ClinicStudent

Top 5:
Addicted
You Love Me
Can I Have A Kiss
Maybe
Honestly

Nearly flawless list.

Switch Addicted for either Dark Side or SUBG and you have my list.

[Heartbeat Song]

Originally posted by xDiamondx

Nearly flawless list.

Switch Addicted for either Dark Side or SUBG and you have my list.

non singles though?

[Chivas]

Originally posted by Chivas

Attention y'all!

I am proposing that the OP of our base thread be replaced. It's not that I don't appreciate Ryan and his contributions to our base. It's just that I feel that someone who is more active here should be the OP. Given his popularity, his high rate of activity here on ATRL, and his recent contributions to the original post of this thread, I propose we change the OP to Addicted.

Most importantly, we would need Ryan's approval for such a change. I would also like to her from the rest of the Mafia concerning this change.

Originally posted by Chivas

I wonder how long it's going to take Ryan to respond to my post and prove my point

[Chivas]

Originally posted by ClinicStudent

Top 5:
Addicted
You Love Me
Can I Have A Kiss
Maybe
Honestly

Another criminally underrated song

[Troye]

Originally posted by ClinicStudent

non singles though?

Hmm. You're right. I missed that. Then pretty much How I Feel in place of Addicted. Been awhile since I listened to Addicted.

[lpd446]

I spot more honestly stans

[mike_10]

Originally posted by Chivas

You Thought Wrong hasn't been eliminated

WaiT... i meant to say "What's Up Lonely", my bad

Originally posted by ClinicStudent

Finally some taste, I canNOT stand when people praise these songs. They are not worthy of Kelly's talent.... however, I still wouldn't give them a zero.

YTW and Einstein are my 2 lowest songs for the rate.

THIS!!!!

Einstein deserved a 1 or 2 from me, but since Kelly's vocals were on it, i gave it a 3

Still one of my lowest scores in the rate

[KCLA]

Originally posted by ClinicStudent

Don't any of y'all come for Hello. Hello could be a single.

And although the live version of BD is the most flawless, the thankful version does NOT deserve a 0. Some of you need to get a clue. Bye.

Single my ass. That song don't deserved to be recorded

[Heartbeat Song]

Originally posted by KCLA

Single my ass. That song don't deserved to be recorded

[stoopidjenna]

Hello is amazing Some of Kelly's best lyrics against a bop worthy melody I'd be here if Kelly recorded an album of songs like Hello and Ready.

[vonno]

Originally posted by lpd446

I spot more honestly stans

they see the light

[Heartbeat Song]

Originally posted by KCLA

WYWBMD is flawless, is one of the few songs that I have on my phone from AIEW IHMFLY is one of the best songs from Kelly.

Both got 5's from me...both in by bottom 15...