"All hail Nicki Minaj" -Chron + Rolling Stones Review
Quote:
All hail Nicki Minaj. Again.
The youngest judge on the rebooted “American Idol” panel continues to prove the biggest reason to watch. And Mariah Carey continues her decent into a sleepy-smiled non-entity. (Someone get her a Red Bull already.)
The remaining guys were put through a final solo round before another cut. And Nicki provided the most razor-sharp critiques I think I’ve heard in any season. Seriously — she does NOT play. And she is not one for standard niceties. This girl was on fire with her critiques.
After Wednesday's group rounds, which decimated the field of Idol wannabes, the boys last night had one more chance to sing for their suppers and prove that they are live-show ready. While all the judges (except Nicki) slept through the proceedings, a few people did well, but no incredible standouts emerged. Nicki was on a roll last night. After Papa Peachez failed to step up, she told him, "That flame is burned out. I'm so disappointed," then hastened to add, "I still love you." But that's probably not enough to cling to at night. While Nicki may have sounded harsh to those she was dismissing, she correctly pointed out, "If you didn't fight for your life tonight, you should be pretty upset with yourself."
I have to admit I am quite surprised at how Nicki turned out to be the most critically acclaimed aspect of the show. I'm really happy for her. She's an excellent judge.
She gives really good advice.
Mariah is just sitting looking tired.
Randy got really boring after 11 seasons
Keith is not that interesting either but at least he tries to be dope.
I feel like Simon's legacy lives on in Nicki and she's being that sharp and honest judge like Simon was/is.
She is hands down the best judge. I sometimes think she can be a little rude when she's laughing right in their face but it's not intentionally mean spirited - I'd do the same.
She's great. I hope she doesn't another season
I'm really so happy she's getting all this good energy/reviews from her stint on Idol. Last year dragged her through the pits, I hope Idol is able to revitalize her.