[@michael]

Originally posted by madonnas

BGDC or All Good Things need to be kicked to the CURB

I will say that NEITHER of those will be the final song tonight

[CBXC]

This the first elimination of the night that I'm truly upset with. This was probably my second favorite X song off BTB.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by @michael.

I will say that NEITHER of those will be the final song tonight

Well then I hope it's Oh Mother

[Konichiwa]

Originally posted by madonnas

BGDC or All Good Things need to be kicked to the CURB

All Good Things should be top 10.

BGDC should leave ASAP.

[Wet]

Mercy On Me, Glow & Wind It Up


WHAT THE **** IS WRONG WITH U PEOPLE?

[Giselle]

Understand is one of the better tracks on Back to Basics

[Qwerty]

Originally posted by @michael.

I will say that NEITHER of those will be the final song tonight

Good. All Good Things is flawless.

[Strangergab]

Originally posted by Qwerty

Good. All Good Things is flawless.

.

[@michael]

Originally posted by madonnas

Well then I hope it's Oh Mother

What kinda PROPHECY

Average: 7.5
High Score: 10 (Honey, Duca, borntodie)
Low Score: 3 (nicklada, alex_bmkx)

Glad to see this one go finally! It was by far the lowest-rated song left for me. The rest got at least an 8 from me. This is another song about X's abusive father. She wrote about this subject on Stripped on a song titled, "I'm OK." I guess I feel the same way about this as I feel about "Still Dirrty". Since she's already wrote a similar song on Stripped, I don't know why this song is necessary. I understand domestic abuse is a serious issue, but I don't feel like X brought anything new to the table with this song.

[madonnas]

Finally. Worst song on Back to Basics!!!

[Luigi]

Originally posted by @michael.

Average: 7.4118
High Score: 10 (Rolland, nicklada, Strangergab, Run The World, Duca, Victoria, Wet, Luigi, alex_bmkx, Jdella11, CBXC)
Low Score: 1 (Konichiwa)

Eh, this song is average. It shouldn't be this close to the Top 20. Something I've realized when doing this rate: BTB has lots of religious material. Lots of talk about God, praying, spirituality. It's just a curious observation since the religious aspects weren't really promoted or talked about in the reviews. The long note at the end of this song is really the best part - very impressive from X! What are y'alls thoughts?

This should've been in the top twenty.

[@michael]

There were no Fergie songs tonight The Queen slaying!

[madonnas]

Originally posted by @michael.

There were no Fergie songs tonight The Queen slaying!

Even though I've given her a hard time for BGDC I am glad the all holy first four singles are still in. I wish I had given them all 10s.

[Giselle]

Now Mercy On Me being out this early is utter ********.

[.Chad.]

Welcome lives to slay another day.

[Qwerty]

YES! I gave this a 7.5. My #41. I rated it too high. I rated two other Xtina songs that are still in lower, but I think this is my least favorite of the three.

[MP2K]

There's no hope for Gwen at all.

[@michael]

Originally posted by madonnas

Even though I've given her a hard time for BGDC I am glad the all holy first four singles are still in. I wish I had given them all 10s.

BGDC was the 4th single "Clumsy" was the 5th.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by MP2K

There's no hope for Gwen at all.

Yummy and Wind it Up being so low There's hope in the title track and Wonderful Life I guess.

[Qwerty]

Originally posted by madonnas

I am glad the all holy first four singles are still in.

BGDC was single #4.