No matter what she does from now on, even if she doesn't release one pop album from now on, she's a legend that will be remembered forever. The same can't be said for pop girls who have tens of #1s.

Just like David Bowie, while she didn't always slay the charts, she ALWAYS was and will be remembered. Why is that?

Is it her undoubtable talent? Her influence on the pop music scene? Or the quality of her music?

She isn't.

Sometimes, things just are the way they are!

.

Because only legends make that much impact in such a short amount of time

Well she isn't so I don't know.

Maybe on ATRL

In the real world she still has a long way to go given her fairly rapid decline, no offence

Because she had the biggest peak in pop music history, that's why.
Oh and also last year's Oscars performance.

No she is not. A high peak in music doesn't make you a legend. She has a long way to go -- and her next album is going to either make or break her so postpone the legend talk.

Maybe in your heart

Because talent always wins

no just..................no
Im a Monster but sis........................................what have you been smoking and where did you get it....?

Gaga, like every single artist that debuted this century, has a lot more to prove before we start calling her a legend.

It's safe to presume that she will be remembered as a legend in the future though, the impact is there, but it's a little to early to make this thread.

Because talent

because she is multi-talented

Her rise to fame was so meteoric that even after her string of missteps she still feels like a force much larger than some of her peers