It's hard for me to even pick a favorite combination because I'm generally more attracted to guys bodies' than the characteristics of their appearance. However, if I had to choose I'd say light colored hair (pref. buzzed), very pale skin, and dark eyes.
A Prince Eric type. Jet black hair with light blue eyes. Really thick eyebrows - a young Peter Gallager/Keira Knightly type. Long lean body with a hairy chest and legs, pale skin, big feet.