I mean, it was already TOP 3 at that point but why did the PRODUCERS gave her a song choice that is not winning material. I mean, why would all of songs to display her potential and capability, it was chosen from the Happy Feet Soundtrack Keep in mind, this was not her song choice, but by the PRODUCERS. The judges gave lukewarm receptions and disappointing critiques and thus America voted, and she was eliminated. And next week, went on the Battle of the two Davids 7 years later, im still not over by this
I mean, why would all of songs to display her potential and capability, it was chosen from the Happy Feet Soundtrack 
Keep in mind, this was not her song choice, but by the PRODUCERS. The judges gave lukewarm receptions and disappointing critiques and thus America voted, and she was eliminated. And next week, went on the Battle of the two Davids 
7 years later, im still not over by this 
Yes! The judges/producers had it out for her!! America was smart enough to see through their machinations though! 
