Discussion: Is Carly Rae Jepsen officially NOT a 2-hit Wonder?

Mattyboy

Quote:

39. I Really Like You (+44)

Her lead single officially moves into the top 40 in the Hot 100.

Will ATRL still consider her a two-hit Wonder?

Slayonce

No.

BadBoy

No.

Dämon

dussymob

Sadly they was considering her a one hit wonder but who cares what ATRL thinks.

Mark Rih

YR.

Hell No.

Dollas n Diamonds

I'm more interested in why that happened

No

TaylorFantasy

Lmao atrlers can stay denying Lord Carly her #POWER it won't matter anyway when she's delivering in both quality and chart success <3

superben

Plus All That is coming for #1, year-end lists and the Grammy.

Girlicious

i really like you should have charted higher than that... but i don't consider her a one-hit wonder since she is a well-known name

SebaMonster

Yes. Carly has three hits now.

Queen.

Nemo

Nope

Rogue

2-Hit Wonder doesn't even exist.

Squall

It is not a hit.

Ariana Grande

Quote:

Originally posted by Sazare

She already officially wasn't a one-hit wonder when Good Time went Top 10.

But who will remember that in 10 years? No one's gonna look back and see/say "Carly Rae, the girl who sang in Good Time". Nor will she be remembered as some sort of pop icon. She will be remembered as the girl who sang that one annoying song that played everywhere.

Superbitch

N

O

P

E

InVy

Quote:

Originally posted by Dollas n Diamonds

I'm more interested in why that happened

Justin helping poor people as usual.

wesleywalrus

Until she gets a 3x platinum single, probably not.

The song is really great though.

Sazare

Quote:

Originally posted by Ariana Grande

But who will remember that in 10 years? No one's gonna look back and see/say "Carly Rae, the girl who sang in Good Time". Nor will she be remembered as some sort of pop icon. She will be remembered as the girl who sang that one annoying song that played everywhere.

Well. I deleted my post because I realized I misread the title but this is such a bad argument. Plenty of once-popular artists have entire discographies that are forgotten. Does that make them "no-hit wonders"? Is Celine now a one-hit wonder because her only truly remembered song now is "My Heart Will Go On"?

Regardless of whether anyone remembers a song years and years on, it doesn't change the fact that, at one point, it entered the zeitgeist.