What do ya'll think? Has Taylor grown enough as a performer to be able to take on the largest musical platform ever?

Also, would it have made more sense for Taylor to have performed after enjoying such immense commercial success in the past 6 months with 2 (soon to be 3) consecutive & certifiable hits from her latest era? Katy performed her two recent mega hits 'Roar' and 'Dark Horse' but her setlist / song choice was kinda questionable, wouldn't you say? Or maybe just a tad basic?

What would Taylor have performed? What would she have done differently? Who would she have brought on stage with her / covered / or altered from her previous material?

Also, comparatively what would 1989's sales look like next week / where would total sales be as a result of Taylor performing

----

I know that's a lot of questions but I just wanna gauge what ATRL thinks about what Taylor can do / could have done, go

Yes. By a thousand miles. Hell they could've gotten Coldplay, but noooo it's too mature for families.

Of course not!

NO.

Hell no.

Ofc.

Lol, no.

this is a troll thread right?

Obviously not.

As predicted KatyCats will say no. Taylor destroyed Katy almost every single department and SB is the only thing they have to back up

No

NO

She would have been a very good choice, but i think Katy was just fine. I feel like the setlist was very weak tho, she has an impressive catalogue and this performance didnt represent it that well in my opinion!

I'm not a fan of either (clearly) but yeah, after the abysmal performance Katy put on tonight, I think Taylor would have ruled the stage. But it is what it is. I don't think we'll see another Pop girl for awhile because Katy's half-time show.

(WHY would Katy END with "Firework"?!?!? End with an upbeat song (like "Roar")! "Firework" drained ALL the energy in the room! )

It would have been the same. Overproduced theatrics over actual performing abilities.

NO

Nope!

1. Katy has more hits
2. Katy is a far better performer

No. I feel like most of her songs are too personal for them to resonate with the SB crowd. Headlining SB halftime could potentially hurt her.