Which song do you think is more overrated on ATRL?

Neither.

We Found Love.

We Found Love is incredibly overrated on this site.

They're both fantastic songs and are rightfully credited as such.

WFL

At least Toxic is a good song.

We Found Love

It's good, but it's not great.

And it's far from being Calvin's best song.

WFL

WFL, honestly. It's a brilliant song, I still bop, etc, but it's not exactly that forward-thinking sonically. Toxic was a sort of step for pop music in a particular direction, whereas I don't feel as though WFL represented much of a shift that wasn't already there.

WFL but only because Toxic is one of the best pop songs of all time. Deal with it.

WFL and it's not even a good song.

I love both

Toxic by far

At least people know WFL in real life

I don't know anybody irl who knows Toxic. Nearly everyone knows We Found Love

BOMT would have been a better comparison.

Which makes toxic underrated

WFL. It was huuuge but that was it.


Toxic is a classic pop song with an iconic video.

I don't appreciate you making this thread as a response to mine

OT: They're both amazing and deserve every accolade that was given to them. They're a rare breed of trascendental pop songs, which sounds oxymoronic but it's true!

Exactly.