I have the Good Morning America one on my iTunes live version and it's amazing.
ps: it looks like, again, his best song is flopping on radio. Unless it's just taking off very slowly...Leavin' had the same run and ended up going to one. If his bullet drops below 100, then I'll start worrying...
maybe it's just me but I like the acoustic version better. I thought the live one was good as well but I've just always been a fan of acoustic performances. It takes real talent to knock those out of the park and I think he did a really good job. I have yet to see him give a bad live performance acoustic or with a band and though I'm not really into his style of music I'm really tempted to go and buy the new single.
As for the single flopping, I've only heard it on the radio once, but I think it will pick up speed after the video is released. I will honestly be shocked if it doesn't break top 40.