I'm gonna start a thread on rating avatars. Here's how it goes:

First, I'm gonna show you an avatar every week.
Then. rate it between 1-10 (1 being the lowest and 10 being the highest [no points/decimals, if there are, round it off.])
And lastly, we'll post the score then, and I'll show you another avatar.

This will start tomorrow.
(If there's an avatar you want everybody to rate, feel free to send it to me by PM.)

Sounds like a really good idea. This subforum could use a fun thread like this.

aww sounds fun

The first avatar to rate is:

J@r3d's Rihanna - Disturbia


My Rate:
9

7/10

9.5/10

Despite the fact that there are many good Disturbia avatars, this one has to be myfavourtie. The caps are very well done, and I also changed my opinion on the animation. I used to think it was too plain, but I now think that it stands out mainly because unlike many other animations I saw, it isn't blurry or too dark. I'm also happy that instead if cramming the spider in the middle of the avatar, you gave it its own space which helps it stand out. Oh, and the orange background completely fits the avatar and caps.

Truly well done!!

9/10

8

great combination of colors

9.5/10

Now Up:
Just Dance avatars of ATRL:

charmed_kai's


-mUsIcLoVeR-'s


Yahhh's


Rated Avatars:
J@r3d's Rihanna - Disturbia - 8.7

7.8/10
9/10
7/10

8/10
8/10
9/10

10
9
9


just an advice, maybe you don't need to put the avatar maker, coz i think some member will rate it based on the maker

tho it's so obvious

The problem is that its hard to compare the first 2 to the last one. They are too different in terms of caps, animations, borders and the rest.

9
10
7

8
7
8

6/10
10/10
9/10

10
6
8

8
9
9.5

10
7
8