Usually when we talk about most modern Christmas songs, people often say Mariah Carey's Christmas song comes to mind. It's currently #8 on the digital top 50 and trails only 7 songs there. What I wanna know is....and be honest!

Is All I Want For Christmas Is You, overrated or underrated?

Discuss.

You have me on block.

UNDERRATED!
it should be named XMAS' official song rather than Jingle bells

That song is a classic... nothing overrated about it. I personally prefer Miss You Most At Christmastime though.

The only Christmas song that I can tolerate listening to it. Mariah is awesome.

Overrated. Though I love the song. <3

I love this song but it's ridiculous how it returns to charts every December.

^yeah.

but it's the best xmas song ever.

it's not underrated..neither overrated.....
The song is just a great xmas song!

i love this song!

I can't get enough of it

uderrated because they never give it a chance to do well at billboard charts

love this song!

It's UNDERRATED. I love this song, it actually made me start to accept the existence of Christmas songs by famous singers. lol

i love this song! but im mostly into oldies christmas songs and christmas songs they play on the radio. i always listen to christmas music this time of the year!

The best modern Christmas song of this age.

Best Christmas song EVER. Its a masterpiece and really is the official christmas anthem, its such a classic that you can never get tired of hearing it.

Its Mariah's best recorded song too

I'll be brutally honest, I'm surprised there's so many underrated responses.

Its underrated. yes its amazingly perfect, but it should be named OFFICIAL CHRISTMAS SONG and until then, its still not given enough credit.

nope i <3 my bells