Both are Bey and Rih's third albums
Both had explosive lead singles (Single Ladies and Umbrella)
Which is better?

IASF. single ladies,Halo >>>>>

If I Were a Boy vs. Umbrella
Halo vs. Push Up on Me
Disappear vs. Don't Stop the Music
Broken-Hearted Girl vs. Breakin' Dishes
Ave Maria vs. Shut Up and Drive
Satellites vs. Hate That I Love You
Single Ladies vs. Say It
Radio vs. Sell Me Candy
Diva vs. Lemme Get That
Sweet Dreams vs. Rehab
Video Phone vs. Question Existing
Ego vs. Good Girl Gone Bad

I Am... Sasha Fierce - 5
Good Girl Gone Bad - 7

Umbrella is the best single to come out of each album >>

I use IASF as a whole though whereas I only use a few tracks off of GGGB

IASF, of course

GGGB >>>>>>

IASF is a filler fest

I AM is Bey's worst effort next to her debut.

Good Girl Gone Bad is in Rih's trinity and has better Replay value.

I voted GGGB

Good Girl Gone Bad

imma copy KillingYourCareer

If I Were a Boy vs. Umbrella
Halo vs. Push Up on Me
Disappear vs. Don't Stop the Music
Broken-Hearted Girl vs. Breakin' Dishes
Ave Maria vs. Shut Up and Drive
Satellites vs. Hate That I Love You
Single Ladies vs. Say It
Radio vs. Sell Me Candy
Diva vs. Lemme Get That
Sweet Dreams vs. Rehab
Video Phone vs. Question Existing
Ego vs. Good Girl Gone Bad

I Am... Sasha Fierce - 5
Good Girl Gone Bad - 7

I only hate one song from GGGB, while i don't use half of the I Am part. So GGGB. Both are great tho

Umbrella>>>

Voted for the one that is remembered.

Good Girl Gone Bad is way better. IASF was 80% filler

bey's worst vs rih's best? easy.

Both have great singles, but GGGB has great album tracks as well.

Plus it has the ICONIC Umbrella. Meanwhile...... yep, nothing.

Why does it always have to be about sales, for once can it just be about quality