Both albums are good...but what one is better?

I go for Fallen

Nothing can top this. The Open Door is good and all, but it doesn't live to the same expectations of Fallen! Plus it was kind of boring for me...slow songs.

i really can't decide i have both of their albums. They are both great

fallen!!! My Immortal is their best song!!

Fallen all the way!
It rocks from the first track to the last one.
The Open Door is great too, but Fallen is the masterpiece!

Fallen by miles, it's a classic in my cd collection

I'll be THE DIFFERENT ONE and say The Open Door.

The Open Door.

Fallen

Hands down, Fallen.

i can't decide!

Very close, but I think the Open Door edges out just for having more songs.

very hard, but i go with open door, cause no matter how amazing some songs were on fallen, it was a bit too much nu-metal for mee, the open door is a more mature effort, with overall better songwriting and more goth-metal stuff, which i like

Fallen...

It's gotta be Fallen for me... classic album.

The Open Door disappointed me from what I head of it.

Fallen.

the open door

Fallen 1 millon of times

I preferred Fallen, The Open Door has some beautiful tracks but it needed more variety imo.

i can't decide because I don't want to say one is better than the other because they are both better than eachother in different ways