^ thanks for voting

mariah's one is a classic

Tough one, but I'll go with Mariah on this one....

oh lord, Mariah's videos will murder Avril's on every battle.

Mariah without a doubt

Heartbreaker, easily.

mariah....

easily Mariah.

Mariah, by far

MC.

I'm in the minority here, but I'm going with Avril's video

Mariah by far. Both classic girlfriend get at boyfriend for something. Mariah in the bathroom, hilarious.

i voted avril
the video rocks

Heartbreaker, original song/video and the remix song (not video). I find Girlfriend to be a tacky, cheap looking video with the usual prep vs 'alternative' look crap from Avril, poorly written lyrics and **** subject - unless of course it was meant to be a parody.

Girlfriend

Arvil

hahaha...i love both..

i can't vote

mariah