From their debut single to their latest lead single, which pop artist has shown the most growth overall?

Katy Perry - I Kissed A Girl -> Roar
Lady Gaga - Just Dance -> Applause
Beyonce - Crazy In Love -> Run The World
Rihanna - Pon de Replay -> Diamonds

Who? And which one declines?

Rihanna by far.

RIhanna

If we're only comparing debut singles to the most recent singles, then Rihanna. But overall Gaga has.

+1

How? She went from dance pop to........... DANCE POP!

Rihanna

The most growth overall like you state:

Koons is me girl

Beyonce went backwards

Rihanna because she had a much more developed, mature sound with Diamonds while Pon de Replay sounds like generic dance-pop (I love Pon De Replay tho )

Rihanna.

This.

Poll added. Vote wisely.

So did Rihanna? Gaga, ha singles sound nothing alike except Judas and Bad Romance. The Edge of Glory, Just Dance, Bad Romance, Alejandro, Y&I, etc. They're are unique and very different from one another.

Going from simple dance-pop to country-rock ballads with guitars and Queen samples is more growth than the other girls tbh.

What "growth" has Rihanna shown? I fail to see any...

It's between Rihanna and Lady Gaga, but I'm going to go for Lady Gaga this time.

Beyonce



Lady gaga, Rihanna, and Katy still catering to the same crowd.

Although I think all of them have in their own aspect, I'd say Rih only because her career went through so many music and image changes. No shade intended to any of them.

Diamonds is dance-pop?

I see Britney is not in the poll because it would've been a landslide.

Rihanna.

Rihanna >> Katy > > Beyonce >> Gaga