Did the 'Dirrty' music video leave more of a lasting impression than the 'Slave 4 U' music video?

Slave

Slave is more iconic, BUT Dirrty song and video DESTROY Slave.

poll is up heauxs

The original, good girl gone bad video: Slave of course!

Slave

The original one.

I prefer Slave, and think its video is better remembered.

Slave by far, but Dirrty is a MUCH better song.

The one that was an actual hit, Dirrty.

slave is more remembered

Dirrty! The video caused such an uproar when it was released. Slave is memorable but it wasn't as controversial as Dirrty. The Slave performance is more memorable than the actual video.

Definitely Dirrty. Every time i see a boxing ring i see an image of Xtina.

Hands down it's Slave for u.
In every sense.
This is not fair to compare a controversial video that catapulted a teen queen out of the teeny bopper shell and backfired on another.
It's not right.

Let's compare the best of both.

Slave!

Slave 4 U by FARRR. It's more remembered for a reason.

Slave is Disney compared to Dirrty.

Why are these videos always compared? They couldn't be more different.