I've downloaded two PCD performances and I've observed something:
1. Nicole, Carmit and Melody have Mic's all the time. The other three seriously just do backup dancing with no singing (or very little singing).
2. Carmit has a strange, but solid voice when she sings live. Its nothing like Nicole (she's great live) but I think she could do the job.
3. Melody had her part to sing also but she reminded me of some bum singing on the road. She was just nothing like her recording. Seriously. I dunno, maybe its just me.

So who's most likely? They can't all sing equally, thats impossible.

I'd say probably Carmit, or maybe someone new? I dunno how they will market her as frontwoman though. She sounds good live but I didn't like the leaked recording she did. It was just strange.

3/5 of them have the looks to pull it off I'd say. But I've never heard the others sing live.

Carmit such a funny name

The ***** Cat Dolls are going to flop without Nicole.

one vote for Carmit

I don't particularly think Melody is so great live, but I hate Carmit so much, so Carmit gets my vote.

Melody!!! shes my favorite one after nicole, her voice sounds just like christina's

Um, there's vocal lessons....

The only one i know is Nicole... lol

Melody for sure


Is that the one girl with really dark skin and blonde hair?

if you could hear kimberly just once everyone who like it she is better than nichole

either Carmit or Melody or they will bing in a new lead singer

I vote for someone new actually lol (but prob wont happen)

Why is everyone still so thick headed and ignorant?

Melody is the best singer in the group, infact she's one of the best vocalists out there right now. Carmit, Jessica, & Ashley are good singers as well. I swear, I'm beginning to hate Nicole because she has caused everyone to believe she's the only one with talent in the group.

Check out Melody
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N7xUj...20Dolls%20Live

Check out Carmit & Melody. Oh and Nicole doesn't sound too good during "Tainted Love".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRhHS...20Dolls%20Live

There's a Santa Baby performance with Jessica & Ashley singing somewhere on youtube, I'm having a hard time finding it but see if you can.

I want it to be Carmit just so I can laugh at her name every five seconds.