It's well-done and the concept is interesting. It's not a "mess" like her other vids... in fact it's very clear + succint.

So... why? Too similar to ET? What is the reasoning behind your hate?

Hmmm...

I honestly don't know.

I don't hate it, it's the 2nd best from the Born This Way era actually. Behind Marry The Night.

Because it is a bad video.

Too campy/strange/weird.

I love the video though.

Because she tried too much.

don't hate it tho, just don't consider it as a good video either.

i really like it.

Bad video, too long, wasnt on par with her other videos (none of the BTW era videos were), she tried too hard and she looks messy.

best video of the era for me

I find the voice-overs kind of cheesy.

It just wasn't a good video

Bad and completely unrelated to the message of the song.

It was a try-hard video.

It was confusing to follow, the scenery made no sense. If there wasn't the interim monologue the video as a whole would not make any sense.

I feel the opposite.... I think the video looks VERY messy.. The special effects look so dated and the change from colour to black and white just doesn't werq for me

+1

The music video is way too long!



I always skip ahead.

Was boring, not the fun Gaga video that we had all come to expect. The video looked desaturated and quite dull in colour