Seriously, has she ever given vocal advice? I mean Jlow would constantly talk about control or tone and hitting notes, whereas Britney just sits there and says "well done" or "very nice" or "girl power". I honestly think Ellen added more to the table in regards to vocal knowledge and performance advice.

What do you think? Is Britney actually a good judge?

She makes the show interesting even though I don't watch it.

Jeremy, you're still alive

She's pretty good I just hope that criticism is her own and not just given to her through a earpiece

She's better than that awful bitch Kara

Maybe But she's a great mentor

Yes.

I like her as a judge, more so for her non verbal skills

Was anyone honestly expecting Britney to come across as some sort of highly articulate intellect?

She has been doing okay.

Exactly! Nobody was expecting her to say something about vocal advice or something really insightful.

No. She is not the worst judge, even though her comments are not helpful She is better than Paula, Kara and Ellen. She is not that bad tbh.

Well they call Britney for the ratings, not for her advice, I think she did her job... I don't think she will be on the show next year.

Basically.
Personally, i don't think she's a good judge, and her phrases/judgements are always very predictable.

yes, all she can say is "You were amazing!" or "That was not your best performance!" She repeats this every single time, and she doesn't say anything else. LOL

no, Tulisa is.

judge =/= mentor

She is doing a good job and she is a great mentor