When all is said and done, and their careers are over, in the USA, who will be seen as having made a greater impact? Kelly Clarkson or P!nk?

Pink. She's iconic.

Probably Pink because shes a more highly regarded and respected touring act now, and Kelly only really had one big era, that being Breakaway.

P!nk, easily.

P!nk. She's more diverse and unique.

I seriously need that duet between them

Kelly, her songs have been bigger.

P!nk. Kelly is only big on forums, but people never talk about her in real life. P!nk on the other hand is undoubtedly an icon

Pink

Well, everyone's real life is different. To me, its the other way around, I never see people talk about P!nk in real life. I think P!nk seems a bit more low key in the media too

Breakaway >>>>>>> anything Pink has done in her career. Pink has consistency but she never had an era as huge as Breakaway.

Ugh, P!nk, I guess.

Without Kelly there wouldn't be Dr Luke or Idol. Her Breakaway era was bigger than Pink's existence. Kelly by far has had the bigger impact. Some ATRL'ers are talking out of their ass and need to see the facts.

Kelly Clarkson in US while Pink in Australia.

M!ssundaztood?

I love both, but P!nk by far.

It's very obvious!
Albums and singles sales, tours, critical reception>>>

Lol, by far P!nk...but this comparison itself shows Kelly has made some impact.

Lol. P!nk is one of Kelly's idols. There's your impact.

Kelly Clarkson is amazing. But there would be no Kelly Clarkson sound without the likes of P!nk.

Coz she talks about P!nk half the time in her interviews; called P!nk "the voice of our generation" and that music that she makes is basically a shade of P!nk.