X

P!nk.

Talent isn't just about the voice.

Xtina has more vocal range.

P!nk wins in literally every other category.

IA

P!nk

Xtina

Both have a lot of talent, but I think I'm gonna say Xtina since her vocals and dancing are much better than P!nk.

Christina.

P!nk is great at what she does but every album has the same formula whereas Christina always reinvents herself and experiments with her looks and sound.

Oop, I meant to vote for P!nk. All christina really has to stand out is her big voice.

P!nk is more talented at marketing herself. Christina is more talented at vocals. Neither are talented songwriters.

So basically, erm, whatever. Neither are particularly talented.

P!NK.

Pink is the most talented artist on the pop scene right now. She's the full package.

She is touted as a best songwriter, she has a great voice and a great control of it, she is the best live performer, she can dance, she can play musical instruments, she is a creative force behind her image/music.

Xtina is also very talented I think and much better than an average pop star, but I think Pink is the correct answer.

P!nk is REALLY repetitive sound-wise and visually. X-Tina always has a different sound/image every era.

You could put P!nk's last 4 albums into one and the sound and image would be cohesive.

Artists should have a sound unique to them.

Take MIA working with Christina, MIA thought they'd be really collaborating and coming up with a song together. Christina just wanted to sing a song MIA had already written and that was that. A ton of blogs thought MIA was doing background harmonies because Christina mimicked her that well.

Christina may surround herself with new people often, but I just don't see a real creative drive of her own.

Xtina's a better singer. She's a good performer, decent dancer, writes lead on a ton of her music (I know P!nk does too), and has a better and more diverse discography because she's capable of pulling off more styles well.

P!nk is very talented too.