WFL hands Down

Firework. You don't hear many 50+ year olds talking about We Found Love, but EVERYONE knows Firework.

Firework v. Umbrella might be a better comparison.

Firework.

If not for giving the entire world the line "Do you ever feel like a plastic bag?"

We Found Love is already forgotten. Firework will become the new Thriller for New Years and the 4th of July.

We Found Love is better, had an amazing video, and great chart success. Plently still do and will remember it.

Firework is kind of bad and is only remembered around 4th of July or New Years.

We Found Love.

Yes. Besides, there's nothing iconic about We Found Love at all, it's a forgotten single

4th of July and the holidays. Which reminds me, what time of the year if WFL remembered? I can't remember any

Ermmm, WFL by far.

Exactly... it managed to attach itself to a holiday and will forever be associated with it. That's good. In a year or two We Found Love will be completely forgotten.

Firework will be more remembered, but WFL was bigger

so Firework.

WFL gets old fast. Great song and video, but it will not be remembered after her next era, just like Only Girl being forgotten after TTT.

Katy was smart to put a specific theme to her "self-empowerment" song when she did one... now it's a 4th of July anthem.

I still hear firework all the time, while WFL is somewhat forgotten...

Firework. It seems more memorable to me. I can see WFL as being easily forgotten. But that's just me.

Because I don't remember it. And since I don't remember it, it's not iconic or remembered

Let's see if it's forgotten on Thursday...

Any time of the year, it's much more universal.

We Found Love was only really big among 13 - 35 year olds. Not that big of a demo.