This thread will focus on the songs from top albums that deserved to be singles, and would have smashed, focusing on the songs that the GP bought most / ATRL seems to deem the appropriate single choice.

The Process

Fairly simple. The OP will be updated with a potential smash single, and you, the poster, will rate it on a scale of 1-10. (1 being the lowest, 10 the highest). Try to keep excessive stanning to a minimum. Every time we're done with a single, the OP will be updated and I will post it's ranking (If I miscalculated, feel free to contact me)

Let's Begin!

NOW



Katy Perry - Hummingbird Heartbeat

PREVIOUS SONGS

The List

Scheiße - 8.62
Inside Out - 6.30
Hummingbird Heartbeat - TBA

10/10!!!

8/10 Its good, but I don't like the part where she speaks "German"

10

7/10. It's pretty good but not that special imo.

I feel like the song is missing something, like another hook or verse. But nonetheless, would have smashed either way!

8/10

10.

10/10

Literally club perfection.

10/10. Everything I wanted from her that era and more.

9

9 out of 10.

10/10

9

If you guys can, could you post some suggestions for new songs if you have any? Loving the rates so far!

Schoolin' Life and End of Time (Beyoncé), Inside Out and Up N Down (Britney), Circle the Drain (Katy Perry).
Fire Bomb and G4L (Rihanna), I'm The Best and Dear Old Nicki or Save Me (Minaj). I can't think of any more

9/10

The song is FIRE.

8

Government Hooker shoulda been the 5th single

10/10


Literally one of her best songs ever. Such a crime it was not given the single treatment.

8