A little girl crashed, all 18 Persons ignore (Update)
Quote:
Hover over to the button beside the "360p" and click on "CC" to turn on the translations. Fast forward to 1:05 for the video.
This incident occured in Huangqi, Foshan, Guangdong, China. A girl was walking while a van was coming and suddenly crashed the girl. But, rather than stopped to save the girl, the driver chose to start the van, which rolled over the girl! After the van escaped, totally 18 persons passed by the girl. However, none of them stopped and helped her. What's worse, during this period, one more van rolled over the girl!! And, finally, a middle-aged woman, the 19th person, helped the poor girl and put her in a safer place, then the girl's mother came up. Of course, the parents were badly sad. Currently the little girl is still in a critical condition.
A Chinese toddler who was ignored by at least 18 passers-by as she lay bleeding and unconscious in the street, has died, the hospital treating her said Friday, in an incident that has shocked the nation.
The plight of the two-year-old girl, nicknamed Yue Yue, captured the public imagination after surveillance camera footage showed her being knocked down first by a van and then several minutes later by a small truck.
At least 18 people were shown walking past the girl as she lay in the street critically injured, before a female garbage collector finally picked her up and moved her to the curb.
Several passers-by can be seen stopping to look down at the girl before carrying on, and their failure to help her has triggered speculation the country’s rapid development and has made people more selfish.
Millions of Chinese went online to watch the grainy footage of the incident, which took place on October 13 in a narrow market street in the southern Chinese city of Foshan.
China’s hugely popular weibos — microblogs similar to Twitter — have buzzed with the incident since the video emerged, with many online commentators hailing the garbage collector as a hero.
But there has also been much soul-searching about why both the drivers who hit Yue Yue and the passers-by in China’s wealthiest province, Guangdong, chose to leave her for dead rather than stop and help.
“The little girl’s destiny made us ashamed because she left this world painfully due to our indifference and neglect,” posted one commentator online after the hospital treating Yue Yue said she had died.
A commentary in Friday’s Global Times daily said the incident had exposed the “dark side” of Chinese society.
“The Yue Yue incident reminds us of where China is standing on the ladder of its moral development,” it said. “This is what happens in a modern society when many decisions are shaped at a fast pace.”
A senior official in Guangdong said the tragedy should be a “wake-up call” for society.
“We should look into the ugliness in ourselves with a dagger of conscience and bite the soul-searching bullet,” said Wang Yang at a provincial meeting, according to China’s official Xinhua news agency.
Some commentators speculated that the failure to help Yue Yue was motivated by fear of being blamed for her injuries after a high-profile 2006 case in which a driver who stopped to help an elderly woman was later prosecuted.
Peng Yu, then 26, said he stopped after seeing the woman fall in the eastern city of Nanjing, but she accused him of knocking her down with his car, and a court later ordered him to pay her 45,000 yuan (US$6790) in damages.
“The judge in Peng Yu’s case in Nanjing has destroyed the kindness of a whole nation and it is difficult to recover,” wrote one weibo user on Friday.
Retired sociologist Xia Xueluan of Peking University said the Peng Yu case was a turning point in recent Chinese history, after which many people feared a backlash for doing the right thing, the way heroes of his childhood always did.
“After Peng Yu, this is China’s moral quandary. When we were small, we had no such trouble knowing right from wrong. We had Lei Feng to look up to,” Xia told AFP.
Lei Feng was a Chinese army soldier whose selfless service to the Communist Party, Chairman Mao Zedong and China’s people was immortalised in a nationwide propaganda campaign targeting the country’s youth after his death in 1962.
“Today, we have no Lei Feng,” Xia said.
Psychologist Hu Shenzhi of the Guangdong Sunflower Counseling Center said Chinese today are stressed knowing that social services have not developed as fast as the economy, so many fear debt if they fall ill or are in an accident.
“Under the circumstances, there’s slim chance of helping others. If the two drivers stopped to help the kid, they wouldn’t have had the chance to get away, then they would be asked to pay lots of money,” Hu told AFP.
“As for the 18 passers-by, if they helped, they would probably be blamed for causing the accident. In China, everyone’s trying to protect himself,” he said.
Police in Foshan said the drivers of both vehicles that hit the young girl had been detained and would face trial.
One was detained the night of the accident and the other gave himself up three days later, police said.
This is so messed up.. 18 people passed by her and some did not even make eye contact with the child..
Why was this girl out in the first place walking in the street?
It's not surprising they didn't help. It's called the bystander effect or diffusion of responsibility. The more people around, the less likely someone is of helping because of fear of embarrassment or simply because they think someone else will help. There are heaps of youtube videos on it.
Reddit: In China, this kind of situation is referred to as the 'Peng Yu' effect. Before you condemn the BYSTANDERS, you have to understand their situation. The law right now in China means that many victims of traffic accidents, or people who have fallen ill in the street have actually successfully sued the people that helped them for sums of money that could easily destroy lives, even if there is no evidence that they are the ones that caused the accident (because they were not).
"Nanjing judge" refers to the infamous 2006 case of a man named Peng Yu who helped a woman to the hospital after she had fallen only to have the old woman accuse him of knocking her down. The Nanjing judge in that case ultimately ruled that common sense dictated that only the person who hit her would take her to the hospital, setting a precedent that continues only further discourages and reinforces many Chinese people's wariness to help others in similar situations.
