Who do you believe in more? Do you really think critics are mostly right all the time? Why would you think that? Discuss

general public has bad taste but both to some extent

Katy and Rihanna stans voted for the general public.

Critics have horrible taste

I refuse to vote. Some critics are very parcial, and sometimes the general public is dumb enough so I don't know what to say.

General public. I can't take most critics seriously, they are biasd most of the time or make up stupid ****.

Critics are less stupid and have better taste in music.

You're the wrong stan to bring this up honey

Both have their tasteless hacks.

Critics can be a hot mess sometimes, but they have better taste than general public.
Most of the general public are just followers and uninformed with a lot of music that's out there.

I don't know to be honest. I believe in what I hear.
If I don't like it no matter how popular that song is I wouldn't be into it. (Right Round, PRA, Rolling in the Deep)
If I like it no matter how the critics dismiss it Imma jam to it till the end of the world


EDIT: The critics have better taste than the general public. But that's overall and I still believe in myself than anybody else

This.

It depends.

Movies: Critics
Music: General Public

But at the end of the day, I ain't a follower, I decide for myself.

A critic is just a member of the general public with a valued not all the times well informed opinion


it's just an opinion, so I rather the greater opinion rather than someone who has his own taste

when it comes music and movies

the best review is review/view it yourself...

I would have loved to have voted but i listen to the music i want to *surprise surprise*. I "believe" in neither. Robyn and Katy Perry both suck to me

At the end of the day, critics do not pay the bills; the general public aka consumers are what brings the revenue in for labels and their artists.

Critical support is important because critics help to get some artists' music out there and keep it in the history books, but that is only a small sample size of people who care for or dislike an album. People have their own taste in music. Critics even disagree with one another. So, when it boils down to everything, it's you, the consumer, who makes the decision.

Um, myself?

If I had to pick between those two choices, probably the general public, but even they get swayed pretty easily.

General Public, 10 million people who bought 21 can't be wrong