Two legends, Mariah and Madonna, staged their return to commercial success in 2005. Who did it better?

Yes, they're of completely different styles. Yes, it's not a fair comparison. Yes, I'm making too many polls.

The Emancipation Of Mimi.

Both are great though.

Neither.

Not really fascinated into these WW smash albums. I'm more inclined to listen to the succeeding releases those listed above. Although, I'll go with Madonna for the masterpiece that is 'Sorry'.

I don't really like Mariah much. "Confessions On A Dance Floor" is amazing

TEOM. Fly Like a Bird.

The Emancipation Of Mimi easily.

Neither in particular.

Confession!.. It's so cohesive!..

Emancipation by far.

The best comeback album of all time.

Mariah Carey Emancipation of Mimi

Mimi >>>>>>>>

COAD is one of the best albums

I love "Sorry," but I'm rolling with Mimi because I do like her album.

Mimi >>>>>>>>>>

Love both. I have used COAD much more for my life experiences though.

Mimi!!!

Emancipation of MiMi slays all albums in 2005>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Oooo you bastard.... the only album I use by Madge vs. the last great Mimoo album. I'ma give it to Madge, she brought out my inner **** that I ain't know existed.